Bailey ,Roos, Malthouse or Clarkson?

[Adzman 2,154]

Can't stand Mick Malthouse. I simply can't stomach Malthouse. Him in red and blue would just kill me.

[QueenC 74]

Can't stand Mick Malthouse. I simply can't stomach Malthouse. Him in red and blue would just kill me.

Even if he was holding a big silver cup?!!!

[old dee 23,870]

Can't stand Mick Malthouse. I simply can't stomach Malthouse. Him in red and blue would just kill me.

You will not notice him at 5.00 PM after our win on GF day!

[dee-luded 2,959]

From what I have been told, there is a view inside the club that Bailey has been a good development coach but that we need someone new to move us into the new phase and win a Premiership. I have been told by one source that the club has spoken to Roos and Clarkson. Roos has told them he is not interested in coming back as a coach, no word on Clarkson.

Ah, But has he said No to a Coaching managers role, to mentor Todd?

Edited July 13, 2011 by dee-luded

[waikikkamukau 62]

Nobody seems to mention Dean Laidley in any of these discussions - not rated..?

Yeah he is killing it at Port!

I'd take Ross Lyon over him!

[Longsufferingnomore 1,637]

Ah, But has he said No to a Coaching managers role, to mentor Todd?

Can't see Clarkson moving from Hawthorn unless he feels he hasn't 100% support. Kennett moves on next year so I cant see him moving. Malthouse, even if does walk we cant afford him. Roos says No. Who does that leave. Please not Williams. I would love to see Todd there but his first priority with be with Jack. Are there any others. Knights - No. Brad Gotch? Leigh Matthews? Wouldn't mind Leigh Matthews - his love child would be Tappy.

[Guest Artie Bucco]

Dean Laidley?

[Longsufferingnomore 1,637]

Dean Laidley?

Wouldnt he be a good proactive face for Melbourne. Yeah right. Sorry what is his position at the moment. Part time in SA. No thanks. There must be someone else. I am not sure that Bails is still yet to be the one.

[Guest Artie Bucco]

I'm happier with Bailey than most of the realistic alternatives.

Realistic in that they'd be attainable.

I think Laidley is one of those.

As is Wallace, Knights, or even Eade.

Same with an untried coach, like Sanderson, Viney, Cameron, Bickley, Wellman, McRae, Leppitsch, Caracella, Neeld, Watters, McCartney, Lade, Sumich, Rawlings Goodwin, Hinkley or Burns.

Paul Roos, Clarkson and Malthouse I personally put in the 'unrealistic' basket.

Who else is there..?

[Striker475 696]

I'm happier with Bailey than most of the realistic alternatives.

Realistic in that they'd be attainable.

I think Laidley is one of those.

As is Wallace, Knights, or even Eade.

Same with an untried coach, like Sanderson, Viney, Cameron, Bickley, Wellman, McRae, Leppitsch, Caracella, Neeld, Watters, McCartney, Lade, Sumich, Rawlings Goodwin, Hinkley or Burns.

Paul Roos, Clarkson and Malthouse I personally put in the 'unrealistic' basket.

Who else is there..?

Matthews

Blight

Pagan

I'd take Sanderson/Matthews any day of the week.

[Guest Artie Bucco]

Pagan is the only 1 of those 3 I consider a realistic option.

ps. how about Bailey / Matthews?

It's pretty much what we have now.

Edited July 13, 2011 by Artie Bucco

[Tatu 416]

I'm in favor of keeping Bailey and adding to the current coaching panel.

Maybe Leigh Matthews in a mentoring roll and see if MFC could bring Burns back across the boarder. Would also be intrested in making a play for Neeld and Sanderson.

Roos, Clarkson and Malthouse would all be a great out come for the club, but they don't seem to be realistic options...

Edited July 13, 2011 by tatu

[Sir Why You Little 37,120]

Notta Wellman should at least be spoken to at seasons end....He will coach one day.

[Striker475 696]

Pagan is the only 1 of those 3 I consider a realistic option.

ps. how about Bailey / Matthews?

It's pretty much what we have now.

I'm of the 'give him one more year' camp now. I reckon we're on track for that. Give him a year, tell him 'finals or bust', and let him rip.

If he makes finals end of 2012, 2 or 3 year extension depending on how we go there.

[Guest Artie Bucco]

Notta Wellman should at least be spoken to at seasons end....He will coach one day.

Geez you make some stupid posts...

Spoken to in what capacity? With a view to making him head coach?

If not, to what end?

Or do you think he'd return, a year after leaving, to take up the same assistant coaching gig?

What exactly do you use to judge his ability as a coach?

What makes you so confident he will be a head coach one day?

I actually think he will never be a head coach.

[Guest hangon007]

Blight

Pagan

You cant be serious ... yesterdays lunatics. Noooooo!!! Please.

Respect for the players is in neithers vocabulary.

[Guest hangon007]

Pagan is the only 1 of those 3 I consider a realistic option.

You seriously have no idea what your talking about. You make me laugh.

[Guest Artie Bucco]

You seriously have no idea what your talking about. You make me laugh.

He's not an option I'd take, but if you offered the job to him, he'd jump at it.

Read the posts idiot - 'realistic' in that the candidate would accept the position if offered to him.

[Guest hangon007]

Geez you make some stupid posts...

Spoken to in what capacity? With a view to making him head coach?

If not, to what end?

Or do you think he'd return, a year after leaving, to take up the same assistant coaching gig?

What exactly do you use to judge his ability as a coach?

What makes you so confident he will be a head coach one day?

I actually think he will never be a head coach.

Look in the mirror lately.

Wellman is a superb defensive tactician. Huge respect from the players and is a great teacher of young kids.

[Guest hangon007]

He's not an option I'd take, but if you offered the job to him, he'd jump at it.

Read the posts idiot - 'realistic' in that the candidate would accept the position if offered to him.

You are crazy ... he will never get offered it. "Realistic" crap ... you are so full of it.

Edited July 13, 2011 by hangon007

[Guest Artie Bucco]

Look in the mirror lately.

Wellman is a superb defensive tactician. Huge respect from the players and is a great teacher of young kids.

And how do you know this, oh wise one..?

[Guest Artie Bucco]

You are crazy ... he will never get offered it.

I never said he would.

[Guest hangon007]

And how do you know this, oh wise one..?

You are talking rubbish ... absolute rubbish.

If you want to find out something ... go find it out yourself. Because you would not say half the things you do.

Sad thing is some people around here might actually believe you.

Ps If you want a critic on SW ... listen to James Hird or Bomber Thompson. Even better talk to a few of our boys down back.

[Sir Why You Little 37,120]

Geez you make some stupid posts...

Spoken to in what capacity? With a view to making him head coach?

If not, to what end?

Or do you think he'd return, a year after leaving, to take up the same assistant coaching gig?

What exactly do you use to judge his ability as a coach?

What makes you so confident he will be a head coach one day?

I actually think he will never be a head coach.

Wellman has got a much better chance at being a senior coach than Dean Laidley has at getting another gig Artie.

Excellent defensive coach, which is where GF's are won from.

Don't be so rude and arrogant little man...it's tiresome.

Edited July 13, 2011 by why you little

[Tatu 416]

MFC could offer Scully a capitain/coach position, kills two birds with one stone.