King is an excellent analyst and gave sound reasoning to his views. Did you watch the show ?

Roos has expressed surprise at Melbourne's gameplan.

Brad Scott mentioned on Footy Insider that we setup very differently and haven't embraced the forward press. You may think that's a good thing.

Lyon has expressed concerns.

Gerard Healy wrote an article in March which was highly critical of our gameplan.

But you prefer the views of anonymous Melbourne supporters that post on the internet ?

Btw, who are these well informed posters ? And what do you mean "trust" ? It's not a matter of "trust".

I agree that a critical mass has been reached and our gameplan has some gaping holes - not least the inability to perform a decent press.

I am saying that I don't appreciate the views of those two commentators.

I understand what Roos is saying and I remember the Healy article. I think McClure and King, and especially Robinson, are bobble heads that repeat what they hear in the echo chamber.

That is just my view on those commentators.

And, believe it or not, I think that some posters on here have more informed views.

And I am 'trusting' them to have more informed views, not the poster themselves...

But thanks for this, I always enjoy semantical clarification...

And, believe it or not, I think that some posters on here have more informed views.

And I am 'trusting' them to have more informed views, not the poster themselves...

An unusual leap of faith and certainly one I don't share.

As previously requested, who are these posters ?

An unusual leap of faith and certainly one I don't share.

As previously requested, who are these posters ?

rpfc knows his stuff...

You know your footy, Rogue, 45, DC, HT, and nutbean are up there. A few others.

All to varying degrees, on varying issues.

I read some sense on here occasionally...

You do too, otherwise you wouldn't be here.

Nasher too. The opposite of whatever Freak says is usually bankable.

Edited May 5, 201114 yr by rpfc

In my time reading this forum, I've noticed AoB, Stylus and Goodvibes offering some intelligent discussion.

In my time reading this forum, I've noticed AoB, Stylus and Goodvibes offering some intelligent discussion.

I would agree with that.

2 Sheds is also a bright poster.

hey guess what happened, some media [censored] has taken the opportunity to kick us while we're down, can you believe it?

Yes, unfortunately doesn't post often enough.

There are others sitting at the back of my mind, but in general the good posters don't seem to post that often.

No offence intended to those that do!

I would agree with that.

2 Sheds is also a bright poster.

I value the contributions of Whispering Jack, and would like to see more of Finks, Fan and Pantaloons.

rpfc knows his stuff...

You know your footy, Rogue, 45, DC, HT, and nutbean are up there. A few others.

All to varying degrees, on varying issues.

I read some sense on here occasionally...

You do too, otherwise you wouldn't be here.

Nasher too. The opposite of whatever Freak says is usually bankable.

I take offence to this post

I take offence to this post

I would have had RI in there but Tapscott-gate and a few excitable things RI has said has me wavering...

I would have had RI in there but Tapscott-gate and a few excitable things RI has said has me wavering...

Plus the failure to come 'closest to the pin' re: membership tally predictions

RI.

ought to be rethreaded as 720-1080-1440 +

just going in circles !!