why would the dees swap our 3rd round pick for their 3rd round in the deal? shouldnt they give us pick 11 and their 3rd round pick for say our 4th round pick and brock? he was pick 5 in his year!

Makes no difference where Brock was picked. Farren Ray was picked one before him at no.4 in the same year, but the Bulldogs traded him(& pick 48) last year, for pick 31.

Pick 11 is a fair result for us if this isn't BS.

Its is now official - press release direct from melbourne - just read out on sen for pick 11 from carlton.

Its is now official - press release direct from melbourne - just read out on sen for pick 11 from carlton.

Wow!

Brock Leaves

Holy hell

Here we are people:

The Melbourne Football Club wishes to advise that player Brock McLean has requested a trade and will be leaving the Club.

McLean met with Club officials on Monday morning to confirm his decision.

Melbourne has reached an in principle agreement with the Carlton Football Club for their first choice (selection 11 overall) in this year’s National Draft. This agreement is subject to the finalisation of paperwork during Trade Week, commencing Monday 5 October 2009, and the completion of medical screenings.

Source: http://www.melbournefc.com.au/Default.aspx

Edited September 23, 200916 yr by Demonic_Inferno

have you got the web link for this?

unfortunately brock has recquested a trade

official on 3aw from g. healy

even though mike shean had not heard anything saying he had no speed for carlton

GEE THAT WAS QUICK ITS EVEN ON MELB. WEB SITE ALREADY.

CRIKEY

GOING FROM MIKE SHEAN NOT KNOWING TO BANG ITS HAPPENED.

PICK 11 FROM CARLTON

Edited September 23, 200916 yr by fuschia

Now we just have to pray the game has gone past him and it wasnt just his injury that caused him to be useless this year....

wow...there you go

It seems that it came from Brock which is very dissapointing...I can't sat "I told you so" because I was as unsure about this rumour as everybody else, however, I think the other bloke deserves an apology

sorry ignore that.. just saw it on the dees site... wow

unfortunately brock has recquested a trade

official on 3aw from g. healy

even though mike shean had not heard anything saying he had no speed for carlton

Is Healy an official source now? I thought he was a Journo.

But seriously, I really hope it's not true. I think Brock still has a lot to offer to the club and will be better for an injury-free preseason.

Yep also heard this. It will be interesting to hear the full story behind it.

They said for pick 11. to go to Carlton

Like to know if its true.

bit of a shock

Edited September 23, 200916 yr by Deano74

Hardly the end of the world, though it's frustrating that players we wish to keep want to leave.

Does this strengthen our position in getting Burgoyne?

I have heard McLean to Carlton for pick 11...

Any truth behind this? Am I the only person to have heard this...

PS (heard from a family member who got it from a non credible source as far as i know)

I suppose it would make sense with family connections to the club but do we give him his 10 grand back?

well done mate.

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/newsart...29/default.aspx

Article confirming this on MFC Website - mentions trade with Cartlon for Pick 11, needs to be finalised during trade week

WTF BROCKY

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/newsart...29/default.aspx

Read it and weep. :angry:

Absolutely shocked with mixed emotions.

Very curious to see the fall-out.

Go Dees - Building for the Future

I wonder who the club has it's eye on for pick 11? Bold move, time will tell...

I'm sure they've done their due diligence on this...

Hardly the end of the world, though it's frustrating that players we wish to keep want to leave.

Does this strengthen our position in getting Burgoyne?

I would have to say that you may be correct - strengthen our position in getting Burgoyne.

Holy shitter Batman!

Oh well! Would have liked to seen him stay but it is of his own request to be traded. Pick 11 should bring a quality key forward.

I'm actually fine with this.

Never been a fan of Brock. It's interesting that people thought he was in real captaincy contention and he has chosen to leave the club.

Holy [censored]

Wonder how much they've offered him.

Tell me Sylvia is close to signing.

Edited September 23, 200916 yr by 45hotgod16

i am beyond words here

i dont know if im angry at brock, or the club for pushing him to this decision, or to the scumbags at cfc throwing $$$ around again

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

god i hope these guys know what they are doing, premiership or its all over MFC

Its is now official - press release direct from melbourne - just read out on sen for pick 11 from carlton.

well done, credit where credit is due. now lets cut the crap and who is the other player.