Best First Year Player

[beelzebub 23,313]

sorry...was this even a race ???

[H_T 3,043]

I think it's going to be impossible to get near him at family day as everyone will be flocking around him! That's if he's there.

When I stood next to him at this years family Day at Luna Park, there was hardly anyone around him. He was handballing with some kids. At the time, I thought how is this guy going to go in his first year.......Wow. Now we all know. He is a freak (in the best possible sense with ball in hand or by foot).

Go Jurrah

Go Dees!

[DemonDan... 77]

Just interested in everybodys thoughts as to who will win the best 1st year player. Think it has to go Jurrah although Bennell and Jetta have shown a bit also.

Who else could it be.. Geesus

Jurrah might just be the best 1st year player ever!

(Even tho Buckleys 1st year was a beauty- for different reasons, Dan Rich too whos 1st year, this year, was very similar to Buckleys..

Id still pick Jurrah ahead of them to be in my team.)

[thewizard48 0]

has to be jurrah. bennell and jetta will be good, but jurrah is just freakish

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

Who else could it be.. Geesus

Jurrah might just be the best 1st year player ever!

(Even tho Buckleys 1st year was a beauty- for different reasons, Dan Rich too whos 1st year, this year, was very similar to Buckleys..

Id still pick Jurrah ahead of them to be in my team.)

Spot on....Rich may have won the rising star....but I know who we would all rather have!!!

[Fugazi 53]

Jeez, I just get excited saying his name. JURRAH!

[Bagdana 58]

As Grimes only played one, token game last year to give him a feel for the pace let's ignore that and call him a first year player.

Grimes is 20yrs and 3 months.

Jurrah is 20yrs and 11 months.

So in maturity and development levels they are pretty comparitable.

My question is, if we only had room for one of these two on our list which one would you keep?

50 /50 I reckon. Probably Jurrah just because of questions over Jack's back.

[Jurrah Coffee 0]

Bennell really needs to go to the weights room this summer,

same with Jets and LJ.

[LITTLE STINGA 1]

My question is, if we only had room for one of these two on our list which one would you keep?

50 /50 I reckon. Probably Jurrah just because of questions over Jack's back.

Grimes is going to be a gun but I would prefer Jurrah he's the most exciting player with have ever had. Anyone who doesn't think that Jurrah will win the Best First Year Player Award by a country mile has rocks in their head.