i knew there was some fishyness in this rumour..altho nudgey did say brent prismall was thinking about us and close to coming to us

so either someone is playing games with us OR someone went and spoke to a random stranger who he thought was prismal and had his pants pulled down on the internet...

no it wasn't 100% fully recovered. he played because half our list had injuries that actually prevented them with walking, look at luke ball- he's played with it before- as with moloney. However, end of 2007 he fixed it up, sometimes it just gets right, others it takes forver, but moloney is away from his OP days.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but Moloney is out of contract this year. No sign of a renewal yet.

so either someone is playing games with us OR someone went and spoke to a random stranger who he thought was prismal and had his pants pulled down on the internet...

I am not suggesting that i know prismall is coming to melbourne. I can confirm that i have reliable sources who tell me that he wants to change clubs. I know 2 people who know him pretty well.

I hope we get him.

i hope we get him too

I am not suggesting that i know prismall is coming to melbourne. I can confirm that i have reliable sources who tell me that he wants to change clubs. I know 2 people who know him pretty well.

I hope we get him.

i dont disbelieve you. and i agree with you. in that order.

but i was refering to deestoyers who started this thread lol

...

so whats your take on this now? did you talk to someone who wasn't brent prismall?

I find it funny how people are perfectly understanding about Prismall telling his plans to a complete stranger, yet if it was a young Demon kid doing the same thing there would be an outrage.

Yeah, your right, lets bring the gestapo to silence these free talking individuals who think they have a right to talk of their affairs.

total non story...

Find another thread to crap on guys.

By the way, this thread is "straight from the horses mouth". Reminds me of a stable pun.

"She was only the stableman's daughter, but all the horse manure".

i herd billy brownless say that geelon offerd him 2 year contract and are gana giv him a good go so hel saty at geelong.

i herd billy brownless say that geelon offerd him 2 year contract and are gana giv him a good go so hel saty at geelong.

The 2 yr contract has been mentioned for some weeks. Even in todays Age(?). But still not signed. You gotta wonder?

(Hey red &......., what keyboard you using?)

hahaha

yeah, let's hpe he cn cum to da dees nxt yr LoLZ

The comparison to Moloney makes me shudder. Moloney's been an injury riddled mess since he came to MFC and hasn't had one tenth of the impact expected of him and his lack of run almost renders him completely useless in the modern game. Yes he was a good player when he was fit, that doesnt make the return any better though.

Im all for getting Prismall if its cheap, Im trying to block all comparisons to Moloney out of my head though, the Moloney trades been a disaster.

"The impact expected of him" give the guy a break! I don't know what expectations you heaped upon the young bloke but surely you must of known we weren't

getting chris judd when we got him. All I knew of him at the time is that he was a hard at it midfield type who could kick the cover off a ball and was rated highly

at the cats. Cant say that discription differs too much from what we have got from him at melbourne, despite the fact he has been crippled with injury. When he

went down this year he was one of the few blokes bleeding for the jumper week in week out an attribute in short supply at MFC. Pretty sure he also

fits into the select group of actually growing up barracking for the dee's, which shows me his heart is in the right place. Tough, kicks a mile and doesn't

mind a bit of poke with the opposition gives him a tick in my book. Give the guy a chance to give you a "return" on the the investment.

Oh and yes for the right price I would take prismal. We aren't challenging any time soon so we can afford to give the kid time to get up and running again.

Geelong got him in the PSD, we got a first round pick (12?) for Scott Thompson and then ontraded that to Geelong for Moloney, who ontraded that and their first round pick for Ottens.

Adelaide and Geelong did well.............. <_<

Richmond and the Dees got shafted.

Look on the bright side at least the Hawks screw us two years in a row, I hope they sent the Kangaroos a thank you card.

If he is to leave Geelong and come to Melbourne we hould take him in PSD. No one is going to trade for a player who's going to miss all of 09 through injury.

good

lets ge thim then

but geelong might accept prismall for pick 81 or something...with the threat of PSD. seriously. look at the dempster, gardiner and king deals last year

The 2 yr contract has been mentioned for some weeks. Even in todays Age(?). But still not signed. You gotta wonder?

(Hey red &......., what keyboard you using?)

what???

Requested a trade according to SEN

good! get him. pick 51, threaten psd..cos roos are interested too so trade is going to look likely

May I remind you all who told you that this was going to happen.

Apologies MAY be accepted once presented to me.

How do you like them apples, Deanox.

haha well done deestroyers- still a lot of water to go under the bridge!- let's hope by friday 2pm he's a demon

green for prismall i'd take, but cats probably want a draft pick- although- they are going for the flag next year and green could be handy inclusion.

what pic do u recon wed giv up for him?

May I remind you all who told you that this was going to happen.

Apologies MAY be accepted once presented to me.

How do you like them apples, Deanox.

may ultimately happen now given something that happened at Cats, but it certainly didn't happen the way you reckon mate. I asked his mum today and he was DEFINITELY NOT at that pub when you reckon he was.

He will either end up at dees or north at this stage, but don't start crowing champ about your original post. You may get lucky but you will still talking crap about the circumstances.

may ultimately happen now given something that happened at Cats, but it certainly didn't happen the way you reckon mate. I asked his mum today and he was DEFINITELY NOT at that pub when you reckon he was.

He will either end up at dees or north at this stage, but don't start crowing champ about your original post. You may get lucky but you will still talking crap about the circumstances.

How else would I know about it, mate.

Haha go ask his mum, may aswell have asked Chris Judds grandma.

What, does she hold his hand every night and tuck him into bed? The kid was out for a beer. Hes not 16, he doesnt need to tell Mumsie what he does every night.