Whelan to re-sign

[45HG 1,539]

"Baby Bombers" because they were the only team to do it. Never heard of experienced, quality teams winning premierships, i guess before your time....Or, pretty much every year since 1993.

But still, hold your hat on the Bombers team of '93. 1 in 16 years is a great record

[beelzebub 23,313]

lol.. You actually hit the nail.. its about a team.. It was thrown at me that youngens cant do it.. I just proved it can.. Take umbrage if you will.. so be it. Of course there are a myriad forms a team can take.. I just thought we were concentrating on youth.. No ??

[45HG 1,539]

I understand your point. But Whelan can't help a team of youngsters you say? Never head of Tim Watson i guess

[beelzebub 23,313]

Ah..am not saying he cant help.. but is match day the time to do it ?? Almost goes hand in hand with the Bruce/splints issue..If you cant go out and give or perform at the highest level.. why allow it ?

[45HG 1,539]

I say he can perform at the highest level, you say he can't, i suppose we'll find out in the "baby Demons" premiership year of '09

[beelzebub 23,313]

I say he can perform at the highest level, you say he can't, i suppose we'll find out in the "baby Demons" premiership year of '09

09 might be pushing it a bit.. but boyz to men in oh-10.....well who knows !!

[Allen Jakovich 516]

Great news! Hopefully Wheels has an injury free season next year.

[youami 54]

Belzebub, here's one for you, a word association game.

What do you think of when you hear the names Yze and White?

Now, what do you think of when you hear the names McDonald and Whelan?

Enough said.

[Beamer 1]

Pleasing news.

Wrecker has a calming influence on the defence these days. I love watching him tackle too!

[whelan45 203]

Ah experience..yes.. by the time this team comes into its bloom..in 2-4 years there will be no Whelan.. so whats the point.. makes far more sense to get that EXPERIENCE into whomever wil be there

Whats the point...... The guy is a terrific player at the club, one that has given it his heart and soul and is a massive favourite of the fans. He may not be in career best from but he is playing good footy. If a player is not in career best form it does not mean they are worthless, 29 years old or not, just look at Rober Harvey. BTW 29 is not even that bloody old!

You have an opinion but are you honestly this strongly against re-signing Whelan or do you just like to argue, as you're doing on the Brock Mclean thread?

[jacey 333]

Whats the point...... The guy is a terrific player at the club, one that has given it his heart and soul and is a massive favourite of the fans. He may not be in career best from but he is playing good footy. If a player is not in career best form it does not mean they are worthless, 29 years old or not, just look at Rober Harvey. BTW 29 is not even that bloody old!

You have an opinion but are you honestly this strongly against re-signing Whelan or do you just like to argue, as you're doing on the Brock Mclean thread?

I would prefer only one of Jmac and Whelan to continue but as long as we still turn over 7-8 spots, I don't have a problem with the duo.

[Rogue 585]

I could say the Hawthorn area and you would get about 8 schools

That would have been fine - just wondering where we were sending our players.

Cheers.

[Demonic_Inferno 17]

Another quality performance from Wheels last night. Invaluable player to keep on our list.

[Great Sage 86]

Another quality performance from Wheels last night. Invaluable player to keep on our list.

Agree DI, Wheels showed why we will keep him on the list for next year.

[45HG 1,539]

Absolutely, was the only man to stand up in the first half, first quarter especially.

Did it shift your view at all 'Bub?