Player of the Year

[Demonland 72,176]

If you can find six players deserving of votes, list them in order - weighted average this wee a mere .3876.

Thanks folks!

[Jaded No More 68,911]

6- Junior

5- PJ

4- Garland (conceded 8 goals for the whole season he has!)

3- McLean

2- Warnock

1- Wheatley

[drdrake 3,163]

6. McDonald

5. Sylvia

4. Warnock

3. Mclean

2. Garland

1. Green

[w00dy 146]

6. C. Sylvia

5. P. Wheatley

4. P. Johnson

3. N. Jones

2. J. McDonald

1. A. Yze

[Jerry Lundergard 420]

I must have been watching a different game to those that have Sylvia as the best. He(along with many others) had zero impact on the game.

6. Junior

5. Garland

4. PJ

3. McLean

2. Warnock

1. Could not find anyones else deserving.

[jacey 333]

6. Wheatley

5. Warnock

4. Garland

3. Junior

2. Mclean

1. PJ's run along the boundary line.

[tess 19]

6. C. Sylvia

5. P. Wheatley

4. P. Johnson

3. N. Jones

2. J. McDonald

1. A. Yze

These votes should not be accepted.......Good God.

[The Fergburger 0]

6 - Junior

5 - Warnock

4- Mclean

3 - Yze

2 - P. Johnson

1 - Sylvia

[Jaded No More 68,911]

Adem Yze?

Some of you must be really thrilled when a player does nothing team- oriented but kicks 3 cheap goals, two from dubious frees, one in junk-time.

[Maybe next year 170]

6 - Wheatley

5 - Warnock

4 - Garland

3 - Johnson

2 - McDonald

1 - Sylvia

[Yze_Magic 3]

6 - Colin Sylvia

5 - Paul Johnson

4 - Matthew Warnock

3 - Colin Garland

Nobody else deserving.

[mfcrox 143]

These votes should not be accepted.......Good God.

Where are your votes 'tess'??? I don't think that the votes 'vanlo' gave were too far off the mark.

I'll have:

6. Warnock

5. Wheatley

4. Sylvia

3. Johnson. P

2. Jones

1. McDonald

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I'm shocked at the votes so far.

6. Aussie

5. Garland

4. Warnock

3. PJ

2. Sylvia

1. Bate (for the first ten minutes of the game)

[Doggo 32]

I'm shocked at the votes so far.

6. Aussie

5. Garland

4. Warnock

3. PJ

2. Sylvia

1. Bate (for the first ten minutes of the game)

I'm shocked u gave Aussie 6 votes! Don't get me wrong, I love the kid and want him more than anything to develop into an absolute superstar, but there's no use giving him cheap votes to just pump up his standing in the POTY Award.

He had his worst game at AFL level today, with little to no impact. He kicked the ball into the man on the mark, i counted, on 3 occasions! Just to give u an idea of just how off the boil he was...

FWIW, my votes (given its 2am, i havent watched the replay and i've been out drinking since the game ) would be:

6. Warnock

5. Bate

4. P. Johnson

3. Jones

2. McLean

1. Sylvia

Tough task this week. Thought Wheatley's disposal and composure under pressure deep in defence, was poor today. Got a lot of the footy, but rarely did anything really good with it, and often sold his teammates into pressure with poor decisions. I expect more from him. Didn't deserve votes IMO. Sylvia was ok in his return, but only got a vote because i ran out of people to give them to. He will need to perform at a higher level than that next week, probably closer to goal, with Robbo out. I wanted to give Junior votes cause i thought he worked harder than anyone else out there today, but he got absolutely slaughtered by Dal Santo in the end.

Tough week.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I'm shocked u gave Aussie 6 votes!

He was one of the hardest working players on the field, offensively and defensively.

What summed up the games for me yesterday was when Aussie was having a shot for goal from about 50 out. The kid can just make the distance normally, but he tends to kick it very low. The forward line was surprisingly open, however most Melbourne players were too busy having a scuffle in the centre square, leaving Aussie with very little choice but to have a shot. Because he was so far out and kicks the ball so low he kicked it straight into the man on the mark.

On a day full of terrible mistakes, Aussie was one of few players who I actually felt confident with when he had the ball. It's just a shame that such poor leadership was shown (on this occasion) and right throughout the day.

[titan_uranus 25,014]

He was one of the hardest working players on the field, offensively and defensively.

What summed up the games for me yesterday was when Aussie was having a shot for goal from about 50 out. The kid can just make the distance normally, but he tends to kick it very low. The forward line was surprisingly open, however most Melbourne players were too busy having a scuffle in the centre square, leaving Aussie with very little choice but to have a shot. Because he was so far out and kicks the ball so low he kicked it straight into the man on the mark.

On a day full of terrible mistakes, Aussie was one of few players who I actually felt confident with when he had the ball. It's just a shame that such poor leadership was shown (on this occasion) and right throughout the day.

Hmm, I can see where you're coming from but I don't think Aussie was one of our best today. I didn't really see much in the way of defensive pressure from anyone, let alone Aussie.

My votes:

6. McDonald

5. Warnock

4. Bate

3. Sylvia

2. Garland

1. PJ

[Demonland 72,176]

Brock McLean still has a sizeable lead with Aussie holding second place despite not polling this week.

52.289 Brock McLean

34.349 Austin Wonaemirri

29.701 Aaron Davey

27.919 Brad Green

24.791 Paul Wheatley

22.796 Cameron Bruce

22.728 Brad Miller

20.269 Nathan Jones

19.753 Cale Morton

17.992 Paul Johnson

15.996 Matthew Bate

14.482 James McDonald

12.282 Brent Moloney

12.265 Colin Sylvia

10.685 Jared Rivers

10.482 Nathan Carroll

8.132 Clint Bartram

6.685 Colin Garland

5.904 Matthew Whelan

5.265 Russell Robertson

5.087 Jeff White

2.326 Matthew Warnock

1.866 Lynden Dunn

1.805 Simon Buckley

0.388 Adem Yze

[tess 19]

Where are your votes 'tess'??? I don't think that the votes 'vanlo' gave were too far off the mark.

I'll have:

6. Warnock

5. Wheatley

4. Sylvia

3. Johnson. P

2. Jones

1. McDonald

Ok.

Anyone who had Yze in their votes has rocks in their heads.

6. McDonald

5. Garland

4. PJ

3. Warnock

A massive gap

2. Bate

1. Sylvia