Straight Sets Simon

Great effort by Howe which lead to a goal to Jones.

I don't think we are missing anything with Hardwick but your point is still valid.

I've said it once and I will say it again. Scully will be a good player, but he isn't worth anywhere near the money that has been reportedly been offered.

Joel Mac is good, but has been playing too loose on Miller.

Davey will be rubbed out too. Needs to go away and think about if he wants to be at the MFC because he won't play for the rest of the year.

Brad Miller has three goals, embarrassing.

Same as Bate,flawed kicking action that was never addressed from the start.

Whilst probably accurate, it was just the opinion of one journalist from a sub-standard media organisation. EDIT: I agree with Sylvia, but not Morton. I don't believe Morton has the skill set, body or ability to be much better than he currently is.

Sylvia playing well, shame he will probably be rubbed out for the rest of the year. The ironic thing is that Josh Kennedy broke Sylvia's jaw in a similar incident yet got off.

The holding the ball decision against Howe was a disgrace and is indicative of the way the standard of umpiring is heading.

Agree with everything, especially the highlighted.

Green should either play or just not play, not be the sub.

They were and are coached well too.

Draft selection doesn't always reflect talent or potential, some clubs simply get it wrong. The most frustrating thing about Sylvia is that I see a player who has big muscles, is a good height, strong hands, quick and has talent to burn. Then I look at someone like Dane Swan who waddles with tiny legs, is a bit chubby in the guts and has OK skills. Yet, the player that gets the ball more, uses it better and runs all day isn't Sylvia.

The only concern with Cook is that Darling looks like a ready-made star. From what I saw of him in the NAB Cup I still think we will be good, but letting Darling slip by hurts at the moment.

This looks like fun. Garland (6.5/10) Frawley (7.5/10) Bartram (3/10) Davey (5/10) Rivers (6.5/10) Macdonald (6.5/10) Blease (5/10) Moloney (7/10) Scully (5/10) Trengove (7/10) Watts (7/10) Howe (6.5/10) Petterd (6/10) Jurrah (6.5/10) Green (5/10) Jamar (6.5/10) Sylvia (6/10) Jones (5/10) Bennell (4/10) Martin (6.5/10) Mckenzie (6/10) Morton (3.5/10)

No Jurrah? Apologies, overseas so haven't been up to date.

Joel Mac must be re-signed. I would keep Wonaeamirri over Morton. Bate can go, I like Maric but he will probably go. Would like to keep Sylvia under a good coach. NFI what Scully is doing.

Not so keen on Fevola, but also not so keen on Fitzpatrick as the "future" either.

I'm overseas, trying to work out what has happened since I left on Saturday. Why was Schwab going to get the sack?

I am guessing there is a chapter dedicated to Air Jurrah...

There was a nice piece on SBS News tonight, I look forward to reading it.

Glad I am not the only one who noticed, was not the smartest move.

Agreed.

Garland - Outsmarted by Rioli Trengove - Severely lacking pace McKenzie - Learn to kick