Pipefitter

He has been absolutely non existent. He looked Carey like in our mcg finals last year. You almost forget he’s out there.

Frosty was great on Buddy. I feel when Goodwin gives him a specific shut down role he does really well.

How refreshing will it be when a player comes out after being caught out on a bender saying “ I’m not mentally ill, I just love getting munted on the weekend with my mates, just like 90% of people in their 20s do.”

Is he supposed to move out of the way?

I blame that quarter on Gary Pert.

Membership is going into the microwave.

Goodwin surely gets the sack after this performance.

I’ve been making the donation for 11 years. I’m happy this year they offered a $25 dee shop voucher in lieu of a scarf. Id love a guaranteed opportunity to buy a reserved seat for grand final in the reserve grand final if the Dee’s make it. Offer that as premium offer and watch the cash role in. I’ve bern a restricted member for MCC for what seems like forever, and make financial contributions, but if we had made the grand final I would have had no opportunity to purchase a legit grand final ticket.

Really interesting to see how he responds to this. There’s been a lot of excuses made for the bloke over 170 games but the incidents over the pre season point to his lack of professionalism causing his below average career, not he was debuted too early, not he needs the right coach, not he needs a fresh start etc.

Given his off season to date I’d be trying fade into the background, but to willingly allow someone to film this regardless of the substance is staggering. He doesn’t GAF and while I’m not of the idea that players need to be a role model, all you expect of your players is to give their best crack and clearly Jack has never done this and never will.

Totally agree. I’ve been a joint member for over 10 years and theres literally no benefit. Either drop the price or make it more attractive to sign up.

It’s interesting the flack this guy cops like he is the next CS. The guy had a huge tenure at the biggest footy club in the country. He’s clearly no nuffy. Collingwood needed a scape goat if they weren’t going to boot Buckley.

I’ve been in good paddock.

Not that maxy needs any encouragement to train hard, but can def see value in training with another mature size ruckman rather than the toothpicks he’s been training with the last few years.

When are we going to get Range Rover or Mount Buller as a major sponser? Time to profit off those lame jokes.

“but unlikely to play many minutes in a midfield that now contains Anthony Miles and George Horlin-Smith,” wow! That’s who’s keeping him out of the midfield in 2019?

So pumped to see him in action.

“Final offer”?? Still plenty to play out.

Reminds me of the gysberts Pedersen trade.

I thought I was prepared to say goodbye but seeing Jesse hogan touring freo’s facilities makes me feel like a jealous ex lover.

I’m sad to see him go because I love him as a player, but if he was always going home at some stage, he’s doing us a massive favour by doing it now as the club is strong enough now to not fall apart from this and he’s at peak value. We could potentially end up with 3 new best 22 players out of this.

Is there actually any quotes from either Hogan’s camp or the Dee’s camp? Or is it one of those classic “it’s believed that hogan is up for a trade” lines.

I actually agree with something Chris Scott said for the first time ever. It’s a good idea, but to introduce it now after club recruiters have been studying these players for the last year is ridiculous.

It really is incredible how wrong everyone got this. He wasn’t a speculative pick, and at some stages in Tac Cup rated the 2nd best player in the draft.

Loved him. Didn’t love them constantly talking over him.