spirit of norm smith

In the guts only ... not up fwd. Poor call by Neeld. Magner is tough and shows how he can add value at stoppages.

Yes, ditto for me

Burbury is one I would give an offer to. 2 years at $100k. He would jump. Very good player. Cats cannot squeeze all their rookies in and pickup Caddy & Rivers etc. Offer pick 66 and we have a win.

I agree ... Stringer at 14 is a YES. Not at 3 or4. As a key fwd with good aerobic ability (aka Pav or Riewoldt). Huge potential.

I think he would be a good get for our pick in the 2nd round (approx pick 26). Assume Viney used at pick 3. Haynes has the pace and athletic ability. Is a very good kick. Just needs 1 or 2 pre seasons. But has the pace that we need.

Shannon Byrnes will slot into that "vacant" fwd pocket role. Yes and will have some rotation into the midfield. A big YES from me. Welcome aboard.

If we need to use pick #3 for Jack Viney, then YES YES YES YES. Jack Viney must come to us. He is exactly what we need. Tough. Gets the footy. No backward steps. Jones and Viney would be a start to a tough inside mid group. Celebrate & welcome Jack aboard. He is NOT going to GWS or GC ... NOT MATTER WHAT.

MEMO TO MFC: GO HARD TO GET WELLER I rate him very highly. Great ability to get the footy. 3-year, $350k a year contract. Solid build. At 20 yo, he is as good if not better than Scully.

I say yes to "Farren Ray" only at the right price. At the PSD #3, yes otherwise he's 26, a flanker, 2nd tier mid. We have plenty.

Hogan has to be our target. Has all the sise and athletic ability of a very very good power forward. I would trade our pick 4 for him.

Colin is one of our keys to success in the next few years. He has pace, kicks 50+, is solidly built. Was in our best 3 in the 2nd half of 2012. Madness to trade. Move on ...

Ben Warren ... it's a NO from me

Kennedy is definitely a top 10 candidate. If he was available at 13/14, we would be very lucky. He has pace, long left foot kick, and loves a goal.