Ted Lasso

Paddy will be a very good player but he is going to take some time, I fully expect the saints will just let him develop as best they can to take over when roo calls time. Im very happy with petracca but they're probably to different to compare

The biggest question I have around track is does he end up being a better mid or forward? I personally like him being 70% forward with midfield bursts

Considering what we'd have to give up to get him I see little value in the idea

I am 99.9% sure mr dank has the records and knows very well what they would reveal if they ever became public. I mean imagine the stink Essendon would have kicked up if they thought someone had records proving they were innocent.

That's all based on the assumption that he did anything illegal at the Gold Coast, given he was also involved at the cats I think bomber knew all he needed to know. If you have some evidence bomber please come forwards otherwise stfu

Karma.

I suspect crows will want Gibbs again so maybe a three way deal would be possible, first rounder and bugg to Carlton ( they love gws rejects)

We need a genuine outside midfielder I think, but I also think hunt will eventually move into that role

he's a ten year key back capable of being around the mark of all Australian for most of that time. Mid personally be happy to over a very good salary and see if we can lure him home. If we can pay melksham 400k surely we could put 600-650 on the table for lever

Don't worry, saty is just so keen to defend players that he often misses what a poster is really saying, to your point I think yes track is good enough to be a match winner right now! I think his performance in JLT2 showed that

When I look at the best 3 up and coming key forwards in the comp lynch, Jesse and joe they have cover the ground so well and run their opposition off their feet, I've never seen anything to suggest paddy can do this, I think he's a Charlie Dixon style full forward who might be good but not reach the level of the three above. Petracca to me the only real concern I have with him is I am not sure if he's either a genuine forward or mid, I think he may well only ever be a burst midfield player which is fine if the others come on as expected

I think gus plays less midfield minutes which doesn't help his possession count but he still clearly has the same class, very confident he's tracking along well

I won't measure it in goals personally but I think track will have a decent influence for us this year, he is going to be a star

I think petracca is already as good as jake stringer and we will see this very clearly as the year plays out.

Interestingly hawthorn people who had track training there in his under age year said his attitude was the best of all the young players they've seen and they were shocked he didn't go pick 1. I remember asking at the time if they were aware of any attitude issues, and they said outside of him being quite cocky/arrogant there wasn't so maybe it's a rumour we spread to get him at pick 2

I think paddy will become a good player in time, probably not elite but a good player. Petracca is already a good player and looks well on the way to being elite. But they needed a key forward at the Time and we needed mids.

Problem is that it's a crap strategy, why recruit someone you know is a list clogger?

Imagine the list we would have if Jason Taylor had control of all the picks the suns or giants got? I really think sos is an extremely overrated recruiter and has set Carlton back with some of his giants imports I mean why would anyone bother with Jed lamb or palmer??

People forget that these guys cheated. They aren't innocent victims, if they had any evidence at all they could have proved their innocence, they didn't even keep their own personal records. I hate this returning hero mentality, no one should be celebrated for doing the wrong thing

Let's not forget who is really to blame here, Stephen dank and the Essendon footy club for attempting to cheat. Nothing else that happened is nearly as significant as their attempt to cheat and to this day they still deny it.

This is a really important point I think, I may get shot down for this but I rate hunt just about on par with Kelly for talent, i find it unbelievable that he didn't get a rising star nomination last season. A really great example of a player those who attend training can see the talent of but those who rely on game day only probably didn't know much about, I think we might have another one this year with young smith as well, I really think he's one who could surprise a lot of people this year and play fairly regular senior games

I'm thinking we offer them cam pederson and they give us josh Kelly and Dylan Shiel?

seen more than enough of all three to be really comfy with that deal. Kelly may be the best of the lot but the combined ability of Tyson and Salem is probably a slight win for us imo but both sides would be really happy with it

why would anyone want to leave the giants? Sure he might have to take a pay cut but they might win the next 5 flags

Media is his only chance, in my humble opinion