Willmoy1947

Combined Mensa total of Carlton's offer 60

Could result in many damaged fists and fingers...Change it to "if the ball hits or goes over the fence on the full", then it is a deemed deliberate.

What player with inside and outside and all side ball getting and delivering skills has Carlton got that we would be interested in? Aside from getting half their side.

I've heard of blokes having a heart attack with a smile on their face

Likes it open, runs on to the ball, good skills and intuitive footy brain, team player, in a forward line that all disappears at the same time. Not a lot to not like with the right forward coach....

NORM SMITH 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 etc, etc,

Now who do we take De Gonee, Hogan or someone from Adelaide.....hmmm

I would love to see you eat those words Hannibal.....

Typical example of young bloke who gets in the right position to get the pill. If he keeps getting it next year he will be shadowed.

I think we saw a glimpse of his talent with a handball to ANB some two years ago. Carlton had a player called Williams, and i can understand their older cult wanting someone with his talent. Peripheral vision in spades. By the same token we should hike back to who were the players around Williams and how good they were in common sense positioning. You don't go back from not being able to get the ball in the middle to being able to get it profusely to not getting it again. Utter madness. In my opinion Oliver is/will be Viney on steroids. There I've said it. Start kicking Coaches instead of players.....

TWSNBN do not need Sheedy. They need Mitchell and i hope they CANNOT get him, because he would attract the right {new blood}support .

Yep some of these Hawthorn players would be smarter than the average. You would think that Yze is playing a helping role here as well...

How did the information get out and circulated about that Oliver had been asked to increase his standing start from the contest pace? In my opinion that should be completely in house....

If i was taking a Final Four Quaddie at the beginning of this season, no way known would i have taken Dad's Army.....

It could have been manufactured because he was copping a bit of flak. After all there are step ups being needed by all, and not just on the ground...........

How, from the depths of Hades could Gee-long be smarter than Melbourne!!!

Potential to cost.........

Got a call from The Vatican that whispered Hird and Watson both give their Medals back and redemption is nigh. Notwithstanding that they, George etc, are very busy trying to redeem the Democratic Republic of US at the moment.

Sentiment doesn't control Carlton, ask Silvagni

By that last paragraph, either the present coach gets us well into finals next year, or Clarry and the coach goes. I find that rather self defeating. Some people need to pull their finger out maybe sooner.

There's more to this than meets the armpit...

Should have lost it ages ago....

If he does that you get hit in the knackers too much. We need the mix of Max and Luke, and it's on the way.

Agree vehemently with what you and Lucifer have been saying AF, i would just like to be able to see the plan and is Max a factor?

So much for the old committee players rallying around the flag. That's worked out well.