Cranky Franky

"who's midfield looked freakishly bigger then any other club in the AFL" That is a freakishly silly comment - you can say a lot about Brisbane but their midfield happened to contain 3 Brownlow medalists plus Lappin & what they had was talent. .

Once again what did you want the AFL to do ??? Suspend or deregister him because of a verbal allegation when the cops have found no evidence Are you implying we should act on allegations rather than evidence ?

Maybe you could enlighten us on what the AFL was supposed to do. The only fact established seems to be that Martin was intoxicated & was asked to leave the premises.

Quite right. Forget about the Police. The correct way to deal with this is to raise a lynch mob - I'll go & supply the torches

Yeah right - I'm sure if you were unemployed & got offered $200,000 for a year's work you would knock it back on principle.

Love Col's loyalty but really for someone who nearly won & B&F a coupla years ago he has been pretty disappointing. At his best he plays with dash & confidence, takes the game on & provides lots of run out of defence. At his worse he is timid, lacks any physicality, hesitates & won't take the first option & invariably goes sideways & backwards.

As usual Stuie you are confusing the issue. It's hardly a matter of sexual harassment in the workplace - we are not talking about Mel being harassed by her boss or co workers. And by the way sexual harassment is not alright its totally wrong but if you want to be a female TV journalist & interview people live then be quicker on your feet than Mel was or go and get another job - its really no different to a politician trying to change the subject or weaselling out of the question during an interview - maybe Mel should of handed over to Fran Kelly to do the interview.

I have to adjudicate that SWYL is quite correct on this matter. Mel is supposed to be a professional journalist & this is not play school. She should have been prepared with something to put Gayle right back in his box - being sharp & quick on your feet is the hallmark of live journalism. I'm sure that Leigh Sales or Caro Wilson would have embarrassed him on air quick smart.

A lot of History seems to get re written about Jurrah. The Club bent over backwards for him lots of times. When trouble broke out in Central Australia the Yuendemu Community pleaded & begged Lim him to stay at Melbourne to continue to set an example for their youth. Liam walked out on Casey on the eve of the finals. Has been in trouble with the law time & time & time again since - just lucky its not a more serious charge so far. But hey lets not let the facts get in the way of a good story.

BOOORRING. Every 6 months or so there is a Jurrah redemption story. Had a million chances & blew them.

Colin leaving resulted in us getting Bernie Vince. We are forever in his debt. Mind you Tom Scully jumping ship got us Jesse Hogan so maybe Tom deserves Life Membership as well.

I still can't believe how badly Magner was treated. He was never going to be more than a top up player but gees in his last year he was clearly in the best 18 at Melbourne but they would not pick him despite the fact that our mids got smashed week in week out.

According to the statement I read he was clearly heavily intoxicated yet they kept serving him drinks.

Talk about a lame post. I recall exactly the same stuff being written when they appointed Dean Bailey & Mark Neeld. Only one way to measure Goodwin & that is on field results. Anything else is B/S.

Lovely bit of work WJ & I hate to be a pedant but I don't think Marty Lyons & Kim Smith were local juniors - both were established VFA players.

Mainly needs to get more of the ball. 10 touches a match is not enough.

Meh I am underwhelmed big time. Kennedy gets fewer touches per game than Toumpas does.

Some of you critics have no idea. He is actually team oriented & a very smart player - not to mention AA, Norm Smith medallist & 3 premierships - that means he is a couple of levels above Daniel Cross. And his form this year was pretty good. He might even have taught Max Gawn not to spoil Jesse Hogan. Would have made a great asset.

I would have taken him in a heartbeat. Getting on but still managed 21 touches & 5 marks a game & kicked 30 goals. We are desperately in need of some experience up forward to organise the troops & make space for Jesse H. Can't believe they didn't sound him out . Oh well have to do with Jake M instead.

Can't query his passion to the Club but after being in AA form in 2013 he has been a great disappointment. He has been timid, hesitant, scared to take the game on & not much better than good/ordinary and really he has the ability to be much better than that.

He was given charity games that he had not earned but I don't mind the coaches giving young players a taste of senior footy.

TWO (2) Issues for JT and 2 only as far as I am concerned. 1. Panics when he gets the ball & often makes poor decisions 2. Disposal by hand & foot is not up to scratch. Fix these 2 up & we have a player.

Toby Greene's kicking is worse than Terlich's.

I'd take him in an instant. Hopefully has a couple of decent years left. Noted goal kicker, good ball user, has footy "smarts" & runs rings around any small forward we have apart from Garlett.

While I am generally happy with Paul Roos he is an absolute genius in deflecting any serious review or criticism of his own performance. Instead of whining about supporters & players he should have a serious look at decisions made by the Brains Trust this year. Some of them have stunk to high heaven.