Jonesbag

Exactly right, if we get any form of punishment then it sets a precedent for Carlton and even Richmond to an extent. Snowball effect

Surely nothing will happen! My god if we lose our draft picks then we are actually done. Say goodnight MFC

Fair enough, I just want a forward target though, looks like we really are scraping the bottom of the barrel

Pretty sure rookies can play now, eg couch. For those who highlighted jurrah in my 'ins'. It was more a desperate plea to get the man back in if possible due to our lack of forwards, clearly wont be in though. Williams and Cook two prong attack. Why not? Could we really do worse?

LOL Brock Mclean, you stink mate. Ive seen you at tramp and revolver. I reckon you were speaking more sense at 4am than in that interview!

But I thought in the second half of the year we were going to win 5-8 matches and everything was going to be ok?

In: Cook, Williams, Gysberts, Watts, Jurrah Out: Roll the dice or whoever, they all stink In saying that though I will be there Sunday, anyone else going down to watch the match of the round?

Love Jones, absolute star. He is setting the standard of what is required to be a AFL footballer. Model our club around this gem of a player. He is the only one pulling us through the shite atm. Great stuff jonesy!

Probably a pretty fair arguement about the contribution so I will keep that in mind from now on. Although if we keep Moloney (contract update anyone?) and Jones and so on, with gys and Viney and whoever we recruit via the draft would we really require brock? Perhaps if Moloney moves on we could look at him... I would prefer not too

Can it get much more depressing?

Yeah thats not the point in my eyes, the guy walked out. If Tom Scully started playing good footy in his last year of his contract would you want him back?

Before I opened this I thought to myself 'I bet this will be about Mclean' Sure enough it was, which resulted in yet another face palm. No thanks on brock, move on

In: Williams Gysberts Watts Tapscott Mckenzie Out: Howe Magner Petterd Bail MacDonald Williams from reports is doing well at Casey and we desperately need a forward. I wouldnt mind either him or Cook, I just want someone to friggen kick to! Gys and Watts are a must With the outs i just remembered who frustrated me to the point where I was escorted out of the precinct for yelling 'offensive gestures' Apologies to anyone who was near me

Some serious face palming happening here whilst im reading through this. Jackie effing lol at some of your post. To the others who are calling for Neelds head just rancho relaxo, Melbournes list stinks, you can thank Daniher and Bailey for that. Im assuming Neeld wouldnt even look twice at some of our players if he had the chance. So sit back, try and get some joy out of the rest of the season because in reality we arent going to be winning too many games, maybe 1-2. We will get some draft picks and hopefully use them well. Thats the reality of it all, there are no quick fixes unfortunately, just look at richmond. They stuffed up their recruiting mid 2000s but finally got it right, unfortunately we are the new richmond. Go Dees 2013

Surely your joking? Either that or you have never played the game or been inside a footy club. You cant just snap your fingers and expect things to change. The club has just gone through a massive overhaul of its entire FD. What did you expect?

Our mids stink, Neeld is going to fix this next year. People who are calling for his sacking are probably herald sun subscribers.

We should have won the premiership this year with the list DB left us with. Any other coach ever would have won us the flag, our players are just that good. Damn you Mark Neeld for destroying our great list, its your fault Cale Morton was drafted at number 4, its your fault Moloney is a front runner and its your fault that Bate Petterd Dunn Bennell have all of a sudden gone from match winners/dominaters/brownlow medal favorites to absolute spuds! Lets bash on the coach, sack him and keep all of our guns. I hope he redrafts Newton, he was a potential AA forward until Mark got his dirty mitts on him.........jesus

Thank god someone has a clue

Great to see him back and fit

I feel if i answer your last line we would begin to go off track. My point is that I think there are others in line before we should look at trading magner

No we dont, with Trengove Jones Howe Blease Grimes Moloney Mckenzie Sylvia all of which who can rotate through the midfield/forward then, then add in Viney Toumpass Wines or whoever into that mix then we dont need Bate, Dunn or Morton to keep a balance, they are weighing us down atm

Id have no problem delisting Dunn to make room for 4 new mids, same goes for Bate and Morton. They have had plenty of chances and they just havent made the cut, thanks for your time but goodbye.

Unbelievable, why wouldnt you suggest Morton or Bate or Dunn? FFS why dont we trade Watts Clark Jones Howe Blease Grimes or even anyone who has shown some talent this year just so we can maybe get some good draft picks and draft a brand new team?

struggles to shake a tag

In: Watts, Gysberts, Spencil Tapscott Out: Jamar Bennell Grimes* Bate For me I dont think bate has done enough, I do like him because it looks like he gives it his all but his only standout game for me was against GWS. Watts will play. Tapscott hopefully fit to replace Bennell. Gysberts for Grimes if skip cant get over his injury. Obviously Spencer for Jamar.