BIG JIM

Well sheedy might just get viney if he think's he can play game's.I want viney bad but if someone is clearly better we as a club have to make tuff call's it's not that i dont want viney because he is clearly a great jnr but if whitfeild is as good as they say we might just have to take pompas and whitfield. Would love to see sheedy crap his pant's thinking his all smart.

Sellar must go as he is the biggest waste of a draft pick. We should of just used the draft pick on a witches hat.

Im not the best judge of gameplan as i have never coached but is our gameplan a bit basic with no 2nd or 3rd options. Just seems like team's take 1 quarter to work out what were doing and then punish us or is just fitness?

The worst post i have ever seen full stop.

McDonald is a ripper and will be better then all our first round picks. Well done mate hold your head high.

We had the chance to walk of the ground with our head held high at 3 quarter time win or lose but NO they said were the MFC we must give up and get flogged. Moloney must go now he was belted by Ellard who is a VFL player at best and bring in couch.

MOLONEY MUST GET BACK TO HIS LOCKER AND CLEAN IT OUT

Rudeboy you are a worry for me because if you are the man i think you are and after reading all your post's i think im right in saying that liam will not make it because you have gone from saying let's back neeld and giving him time to coming back with this rubbish comment. So this tells me you know some player's dont like neeld and liam is not going to make it under mark neeld .This is a real problem if liam has said something and other player's have said something to there mate's David king and co trying to get the coach out because it's to hard now. If that's the case pack your bag's now MFC player's because i want the best player's at the MFC not player's hanging it's club members out to dry when they think i dont like my coach im not trying anymore. Please explain your comment's rudeboy as you have let the cat well and truely out the bag as you are liam's best mate cheers.You are a collingwood fan after all

The bottom line of mike's article is why 4 year's into a 5 year rebuild are we starting again we have all been very patient. Every little thing that come before neeld has been thrown out,like our attacking football which we were good at and why have all the older player's been thrown to the scrap heap if it was a clean slate. Im happy to back neeld for the next 3 years but god it's hard to watch this side this year at least there was some feeling of hope lastyear now there is a clear feeling of how much will we lose by this week and i go every week and will keep going everyweek because i love Melbourne. It's very clear all melbourne fan's are scratching there head's thinking what went wrong? The only thing to look forward to at the moment is the draft and getting all the player's that have no balls out this club asap. 2012 was another year of were looking great in the pre season it's the best we have trained but the truth is we are worse then we have ever been. The good is that we have names like Jones,Grimes,Trengrove,Frawley,Howe and Clark who we can move forward with as for the rest of the player's i will be watching to see who want's to be part of something special going forward. If you want to keep sooking and trying when it's good by you do it in any other AFL jumper not in the red and blue because we have no more spots for weak heartless player's. Time to wake up. GROW SOME BALLS YOUR MEN NOT BOYS

Jones is by far the most improved so far under the neeld style because jones has always been a hard worker and love's a challenge. We need 25 more like this.

Looks like don maybe listen's to SEN? or reads demonland

I have never seen a team not try to stick to a game plan like we did against the swans this week. There was no one tackling or spreading. There was no leadership on the S.C.G. in a MFC jumper There was no structure in this team. There was no heart or pride for the jumper i love. WAKE UP MFC PLAYERS There will be others who will were it with pride if you dont.

Just went on SEN to talk to KB and the DR and said all us members want Cam Schwab and Don McLardy to come out and talk to us about what the hell has happen since 186. And I'm sure someone involved in the club will have heard me talking and I hope they will finally call a meeting to give us members some home truth's about our plan and why 4 years into a 5 year rebuild we are so bad. 2010 looked like we were ticking all the right boxes and now we find ourselves worse off than 2008 IMO. Don and Cam please as a club let's get all the crap out that is killing this club so we can all move on as a united club PLEASE. Trident member of the MFC.

Why did we pick him? That's what i want to know?

He loved jimmy and is just saying what he think's jimmy would be thinking if the great man was still with us. It's sad but true what he said and there could be alot of MFC player's looking for job's come the end of 2012. The toxic waste must be filterd out of this club asap

Guy's dont think i support what the old leader's did on field simply passing on the info and letting every other melbourne member know what the key problem's are.I for one think it would have been smart to leave green in the leadership group not as captain but just to show some respect to the older guy's.

Mitch clark for captain I can also say for a fact the reason or one of the reason's for our club playing so bad is there is no respect for all the old leader's like Green and moloney and this has made all the old leader's not want to play for a club that treat's great clubmen like these guy's with nothing short of garbage. If you think of it like this you have been in a job for 10 years and put in alot of hard work to become a CEO or manager only to be told by a new boss that you are going back to washing floor's and cleaning bins because we have a 20 year old kid who just got to your work place who is now your boss. This would cause anyone to say why should i work for this company who i have busted my butt for only to be kick to the gutter like everything you have done over you 10 year's is worth nothing.Think about it. This would cause problem's in any work place if the older guy's were treated like this while your apprentice is now your boss.The club is fractured because the company has no respect for it's older workers. This is under fact because i meet with someone inside the club who was very honest that's all i can say guy's

Mark neeld why since you have come in has our club gone back to 2008 again? Brent moloney please pack your bags now.

Every expert i heard speak of watts tonight said he was the one shining light for our team and i agree he seems to have so much time with the ball and i would love to see you get 34 touches in a game MR i know all about the modern game please. Every chance you get you lay the boot's in he comes back with 34 touches in a game were there were 20 worse players in the red and blue and you kick him when he plays well?Great support there lol read all the papers i bet he will be in every expert's best players because you dont get the ball 34 time if you play bad in that role jack played tonight. It means he read the play really well and i saw jack going back into danger positions to make a contest a few time's. I think 34 touches would be his best effort yet. He might not have been Chris judd but he was solid and in our best 2 and top 5 in the game please read the papers and listen to the radio and you will see jack played well so put your watts bashing away when he played better the most his team mates please.I found some example's for you jumbo Herald sun Jack Watts had 34 disposals in one of the Demons' few signs of life. 4. JACK Watts, back from the VFL, played loose across half-back for most of the game, but read the footy promisingly to collect 34 disposals and 11 marks. Otherwise the news gets worse, with fixtures to come against Carlton, Essendon and Collingwood MFC WEBSITE by James dampney BEST Sydney Swans: Jack, Jetta, Parker, O'Keefe, Mattner, Grundy, Walsh Melbourne: Watts, Jones, Howe The recalled Jack Watts (34 possessions) and Nathan Jones (22 possessions, two goals) were the only real bright spots for the visitors, with Liam Jurrah having little influence in his return to the side. I will put some more up in the morning jumbo after all the paper's have there say from expert's who dont just hate but give the credit were it's due cheers jumbo.

Open your eye's i know you hate him because everytime he is talked about your first to jump on him 34 touches check mate.He was great tonight 34 touches after 2 weeks in the 2nds well done jack

Jack watts 6 well done mate very proud

Love your passion mate

Jack watts was our best player tonight you are a bad fan mate. Im angry at the club but dont knock a kid down on form when he gets 34 touches in his come back game he was great tonight and i think he found a spot going forward. Looked great around the pack's and seem's to have alot of time sam fisher like.

Im so angry with this board and coach we are a joke.Jack watts was our best by a mile mate so give credit were it's due this watt's bashing makes me sick sometime's.

I will stand up for rick and say i think he is a good player and should stay for the next 2 weeks to try find some form at AFL level. He was not alone last friday and it was his first game back so lets give the man a chance to fire this week and trade talk is silly after 1 game honestly. Ricky has great marking and goal kicking and tackel's very well when in form.