Slartibartfast

Stengle

Mackin Hore Pearce McNamara Hanks Goldy

Tmac Riv Gawn Chandler Salem Kossi

I disagree. He sways in the wind and goes the easy line. He’s smart enough to see the whole media got it wrong and things are not as bad as are being made out. He’s probably close enough to the club to know more than many and earlier than many what Trac said. So now he wants to redeem himself in the eyes of MFC fans and many will fall for it. Not me. If he’d stood up for us last week then the praise in this thread would be justified. He didn’t. And he’ll turn on us as quick as blink if any more bad news turns up.

He was only there for 36 years because he was holding out for a better severance package.

That’s the way Dazz.

For some, he never will be. It’s sad, because for a coach who has achieved so much and steered this club to that win without Brayshaw, Trac, Gawny and the shadow of Clarrie is a great effort. Congrats Goody and thanks.

I’ll say it: he’s lost the players.

One out of two ain't bad!

Great stuff red and blue forever! Many thanks for your efforts.

I don’t think you know much about culture if you think every player is tradable. Gawn? I think not.

But this isn't "closed" because you can watch it through the wire fence. You reckon that a Collingwood forward scout couldn't have seen it if he'd wanted to. We should be embracing dedicated and passionate supporters, not punishing them. If you want a closed session have it at another venue and don't advertise it.

How pathetically mean spirited of Richo to keep the gates shut so the (I imagine) 20 or so people attended had to watch from outside the fence. All power to your friend WCW.

I know your real name now.... Rob McKenna. A god of rain and perhaps a good shiraz. Try Simon Clayfield's, you'll love it.

I’ve been reliably informed that Gus has already rung him and invited him for a couple of rounds of golf at Royal Melbourne. Not enough Gus, propose him for life membership.

Pennant for your own health please don’t read the game day thread, you’re too valuable a poster to lose.

I don’t think you realise how much he appreciates that.

Oliver Kossie ANB Trac Salo Fritsch

Hey WCW, any sign of Salo? Did he train with the group?

When was the last time he had a full game?

He most likely wouldn't impact this year. He'd not be fit enough for AFL footy and he'd take time to learn the gameplan. Unless we think he is a long term prospect why draft him and give him a list spot when IMO we have much greater needs.

My understanding, and I stand to be corrected, is the umpires review every game and the errors are identified and feedback is given to the umps. It may be that the club gets a report on this that they keep confidential. I wouldn't be surprised if we get a "we were wrong" from Laura on the JvR decision. I do agree that different players are umpired differently. Ginnivan is a perfect example.

There's one certainty in footy. The umpires will make mistakes and supporters will continue to think it's targeted. Get on with it, poo happens.

I would but I recognise I'm on my own pretty much. He's got some great attributes but IMO he's got some weaknesses that would make an AFL career problematic. And we don't need another small forward.