Hobbits's

I would keep pick 2. Port no doubt see trengove as part of their future. The hawks will be keen. So too swans. Unless we trade someone like brock or jamar for a first rounder then use that pick. Otherwise psd pick.

Jurrah and Watts have the best goalkicking ability technique wise along with wona who is a good kick also. Green and Sylvia are accurate. Petterd kicks helicopters, Newtons kicking is flawed and Grimes will play midfield but has shown he can kick goals on the run straight through the middle. Bate does ok but 50/50 maybe on set shots unless. With a better midfield and no positional moves averages will improve. at least we would like it too. Need a bigger presence maybe a Butcher instead at draft time.

I have a signed sherrin with Hancook on it signed none other by J.Watts. That will be a keepsafe.

Cannot wait to see before the game tomorrow night and watch the comedians rip into Maher! What a fruit cake.

not a bad effort winning the comp jtr. have you won it since? I started supporting the demons when very young, mainly because of the entire family follows melbourne.

Yes he pulled out. Disappointing. I think the Hawks would be looking at a key defender such as Tarrant

what on earth! Why would we get rid of our best ruckman? Haven't we learnt anything from Jolly? Jamar is about to blossom. We have to give our midfield something! Hale is not the answer either. He can't even crack it at North. May as well wait another year.

Are we done, all's done, sold to Melbourne for pick 2!

Pretty sure Watts played up the ground as well as up forward. A little misleading mousey. Butcher wouldn't have left the goal square, let alone forward 50!

Absolute gun. Dead set certainty too.

We're not gutter crawlers at Chelsea. We have the best footballers in the land.

Robbo is back IN!

maybe a pick. Robbo certainly thinks he has footy left. remember he hasn't had a pre-season after that injury of his. What, you need help, do you? Robbo is not a dud Rhino. Perhaps you should delete this statement of yours. he's been one of Melbourne FC's finest players in the history of the club. I'm sure referring to him as a dud will upset many. You of all, should know better. Still think he will play. What, even Welsh? I will gvie you the others.

Maybe elevate Spencer in the meantime.

I have just wished Wheatley, Whelan & Robbo well, you fool. I'm right on topic, which is more than I can say for your unwarranted personnal attacks. Pft.

So Robbo is a great player now JtR! Changed your tune? Yesterday he couldn't play VFL standard according to you. :D All the best to the Wheatley, Whelan & Robbo. If Robbo continues may he find a new home. Personally I hope he is a one team player. I gather from what I have read if he gets picked up it might be via the PSD.

He might turn out ok (Bennell). To me he doesn't have that initial power sprint like Whelan used to have. Harbrow has that. Yeah Cheney looks slow, but he is better in the air. Look I hope he proves em wrong. Isuppose Harbrow would come at cost. Like I said ujst a suggestion.

I Hear Black Eyed Peas and Greenday are coming to tour Oct/Nov. Anyone know when the tickets are on sale!!!? Something tells me they would have already gone on sale-probably missed the boat

You goose. Robbo is back in this week. He has kicked over 420 goals and missed a pre season. He is more than capable than VFL standard, it is a suggested trade by me as these threads tend to do from time to time. The Dogs have enquired about him previously, they need options.

Anyone see Newton leave the field with an achilles?

Honest assessment. What's Harbrows real worth then? Keep up the good work JtR. I "now" nothing? Another thing, you don't make sense. Learn to quote would you.

Scott Welsh, Brad Johnson, Jason Akermanis. All in doubt for next year don't you think?

I wouldn't put the Crows in that bracket. Each to their own.

TRADE: Russell Robertson for Harbrow of Bulldogs. Robbo wants to play on - as he stated on Fox Sports a few weeks ago. Bulldogs were interested last time. Aker might go. They need goals. I believe we need a nippy defender to take Whelan's spot. Not sure if Cheney has the capacity to stay with the fast forward pocket type.

Agree on the Pre season Draft pick. That's our chance to get a reasonable AFL player for next to nicks. Hopefully whoever it is - is as good as Liam Jurrah. While you're looking at the status of those players, how about....Harbrow from Bulldogs. I think we might need a quick small defender in the side to replace Whelan. Not sure if Cheney is the man. If Robbo wants to play on - which he stated he does - perhaps a trade?