praha

Garlett, Spargo, Bradshaw, Oliver, Jones, Viney are actually liabilities. We gift teams such easy entry.

Garlett on Degoey lol.

I can't tell if Oliver appearing in so many lists says more about him as a player or about the club that it has 4 year player in its best midfield of all time.

I think he was struggling early in the season. That we've played better football with a mounting injury list has probably improved his confidence. but he was undoubtedly struggling for answers early.

I'll hold my judgment until he reaches 100 games.

We can't build a home ground advantage there with only two games a year though against the same teams. Which is the double edged sword. We go there for money but sacrifice MCG home games. In the process the teams we play in NT have the same exposure us as because it's always the same teams. We can only really afford to play the SA and WA teams there because they will bring crowds. You can bet WC support will outnumber Melbourne support 3-1 when we play them there is round 18. The club should at least ask the AFL to cycle opponents. One year we play Adelaide and WC, the next Port and Freo. Adelaide has played in Darwin 2 of the past 3 times we've played there.

Richmond was only up to a few years ago.

Mcdonald needs to be played in Hogan's role. Push up the ground and win ball along the wing. Play Weeds and Smith forward, alternate Oliver, Baker and Petracca through the forward line, have Hannan there as a permanent fixture. We badly need permanent small forwards though because Garlett is a skid row man's Betts and Spargo doesn't have it. Our forwards bring the ball down but we have minimal pressure there to win it when it hits the ground. We're tackling okay in the forward line but not actually winning the ball and keeping it there. Garlett is an opportunist and Spargo and hopeless. Saturday was an improvement though although Garlett got worse as the game progressed.

It's ridiculous. One posted in here said he "gave up the first goal" like as if we judge careers on a single turnover. If anything what I like about the kid is he plays above his weight and experience. You'd think he had 100 games under his belt.

Melbourne.

Defensive awareness. Zero. Rather astonishing. One way runners the whole way.

Let's not nitpick now. Goodwin has said similar plenty of times. Look back at his pressers towards the end of last year. After the West Coast game. I'm not a huge Goodwin fan but it's wasy to apply selective analysis.

direct copy paste of quote.

Goodwin said: (Jake) Lever, (Mitch) Hannan, (Michael) Hibberd, (Christian) Salem, (Alex) Neal-Bullen, (Steven) May, (Kade) Kolodjashnij, (Sam) Weideman and (Jay) Kennedy Harris All to come back. Hibberd, Salem, ANB, Kade and Weeds were all in the side when we were arguably playing our worst footy for the hear. Hannah helps, Lever is obviously a huge inclusion, JKH is okay I guess. We have huge depth issues.

Thanks for the vague bs. Why not just post what happened?

I left.

If we had lost to West Coast and subsequently missed finals last year, Goodwin would be out of a job come 5pm. Might be time to start pressuring him.

if that's the case hit the boundaries and for wingman to fill holes in defense. goodwin is a stubborn coach. we play like millionaires but look like unemployed Arts graduates: no promise and no real skill.

And on cue after our captain misses a shot they go and kick a goal.

Typical. Our captain has a chance to kick a goal after 5 minutes of solid play...and sprays it from 40 directly in front.

Steven Febey 2.0 Lockhart has an Andy Lovell quality about him too.

If we hadn't played finals last year this game would actually be Goodwin's last. One of the most structurally inept performances I've seen since the Neeld days. Just an awful coaching performance. On top of that, the playing group appears to have zero urgency, directive or leadership.

Jones is a deadset moron. Demands the ball while surrounded by 5 Giants players. Fritsch is quickly turning into Simon Godfrey 2.0.

Oliver Jones Petracca Garlett Brayshaw Mcdonald all less than 8 Fantasy points.

That was an embarrassing umpiring display. Two umpires needing to be told how to count.