MadAsHell

First off, I don't believe it until I see it. Secondly, no thankyou! Thirdly, I doubt it. Both Rivers and Jamar are required and Melbourne wouldn't trade them unless they requested to be traded.

Pick 34, no way would I give up pick 18 for Dawes. I think he has potential but he could still go down the same path as Newton IMO.

I'd be tempted if they offered Westhoff and pick 9 for Jamar and 18. Don't think it'll happen though. So I say keep Jamar.

Offer him 2 mil over 3 years. Surely both player and club could agree to that.

Reckon this guy is alright and could even be capable of being a future FF we need. Reckon we could try and trade Miller & pick 34 or Buckley & 34. What do people think?

Take McLean out for obvious reasons and maybe Bennell also to get both Scully and Trengove in there for round 1. FB: Frawley, Warnock, McDonald HB: Garland, Rivers, Green C: Morton, Moloney, Davey HF: Sylvia, Bate, Petterd FF: Watts, Jurrah, Wonna FOLL: Jamar, Bruce, Scully INT: Grimes, Jones, Martin, Trengove EMERG: Bennell, Blease, Miller

1. Tom Scully 2. Jack Trengove 11. Nathan Vardy 18. Jake Carlisle or Matthew Panos Two midfielders, a ruckman and a KPF. Covering all of the areas we need. No need to trade.

$10 for: Judd most votes for Carlton into, Swan most votes for Collingwood into, Watson most votes for Essendon into, Ablett most votes for Geelong into, Sewell most votes for Hawthorn into, Davey most votes for Melbourne into, Cassisi most votes for Port Adelaide into, Riewoldt most votes for St. Kilda into, LeCras most votes for West Coast. Return $20,163.00

Agree 100%. Trade him for something like pick 79 from the Dogs and he clears a spot on Melbourne's list and he'd be out of contract at the Dogs in a year if he didn't work out and would have cost them nothing. A win for both clubs.

Cheers mate, will check it out. Thanks.

Was wondering if anyone knew when any of the below lised players are contratced until? S. Buckley N. Jones C. Bartram B. McLean M. Bate B. Miller J. Frawley P. Johnson C. Sylvia L. Dunn R. Petterd C. Garland D. Bell B. Moloney J. Meesen J. Rivers C. Bruce A. Wonaemirri A. Davey M. Warnock M. Jamar L. Jurrah ?????

Could go as high as number 12 I reckon. Expect Brisbane to be interested.

I'd like Panos at 18 also if Trengove goes at pick 2. Taking 2 SA boys in the same draft might be good as they can adjust with the move to Melbourne together. If Melbourne draft say Morabito or Rohan at pick 2 then I'd say take the safer option with Carlisle.

By the way PJ played 18 games this year.

When you compare their averages Jamar is ahead of Johnson in handballs per game, marks per game, goals per game and hit outs per game. Jamar is clearly our number 1 ruckman. According to Jamar, Johnson, Meesen and Spencer's stats Johnson is our number 2 ruckman followed by Meesen and then Spencer. A lot more scope for improvement in Meesen and Spencer's games also then in Johnson's.

FB: Frawley, Warnock, McDonald HB: Garland, Rivers, Green C: Morton, Moloney, Davey HF: Sylvia, Bate, Petterd FF: Watts, Jurrah, Wonna FOLL: Jamar, Bruce, McLean INT: Grimes, Jones, Martin, Scully EMERG: Bennell, Meesen, Trengove

Must say I'm suprised about Tuck. Sure he butchers the ball a bit, but he'd still have to be one of Richmond's better players.

Cheers for all your work KC. Lets hope for an even bigger and better year from the Scorpions next year.

That's a fair call, and if he wants to go back home also you have to at least entertain the idea of it. I certainly wouldn't trade him just for the sake of it.

I wouldn't be suprised to see Hawthorn trade picks 9 & 25 to North for Hale & Gibson in a package. North might have to throw in a 3rd round pick also, but that way Hawthorn get their ruckman and a 3rd tall defender they're after. All that will be left for them after that will be to attempt to trade for Maguire.

I'd be willing to trade Jamar and pick 18 for pick 8 as long as Melbourne can make sure that someone like Jamie Charman or Mark Seaby will be available in the PSD. That way we'll get the extra top 10 pick and also pick up an established ruckman for nothing who can give us 2 or 3 years while Meesen and Spencer develop their games in the VFL and will be ready to take over when needed.

HF: Sylvia, Bate, Petterd FF: Watts, Jurrah, Wonna Looking forward to seeing that forward line run out for Melbourne in round 1 next year.

Not one person for Rivers?

I love the fact that you have Carroll as an emergency.

Ah yes Robbie Flower! I've seen old videos of him play with the like of Spalding, Healy and Ricky Jackson. Shattered I wasn't old enough to remember, I was only 5 when Robbie retired so even though I did see him and some of those others play I can't really claim that I saw them cause I don't remember it. That's why I only started from 94' as I can clearly remember from then onwards.