jnrmac

The ice block melted...

The two best players at17yo aren't always the best players at 22yo..... Just sayin....

I'm putting it out there. I don't rate Brayshaw or Petracca. Draft looks average to me.. I'd be an advocate for trading the picks but alas it tales two to tango

It hasn't but that's my mail...

It had one?

He had the scans first.

Stop being a troll. He was pretty much their best player in the GF.

Its very different to last years trading action if nothing else. I love kennedy but its too much.

We arent recruiting for the next flag, We are recruiting to save our club in the next 3 years and protect our young talent allowing them to develop. A kennedy is exactly what we need. Will take the best tagger freeing up Jones and Vince and Tyson and Salem. If we recruit for the next flag you are talking about a team of 18yo's and that won't work. We;ll be dead as a club by then.

Purple said we were using the scattergun approach again. FMD he is a moron

Agreed but inflation has stormed in to the comp and Roos is on a short tenure,. We neeed to do something ASAP. So it could happen....

That';s not right. We were approached by Richmond and he was spoken to about it. Very different to trying to offload him....

I'd like to think the club has done its job properly and its just bad luck. But I have a nagging doubt....

What would that be? Our medical staff from 2012 or AOD9064 from Dank??

Dont think that was the case. Not sure but JT has some scans for Richmond and this was the result....

Sorry to hear for Jack.. How's my strike rate compared to GNF and Chook ha ha....

Could be!

Just got some mail that a trade with JT won't happen. Cant say why just yet as it will identify my source. I believe it to be good though.

Hurts my productivity

LOL

I heard through a relative of his that Geelong was looking promising FWIW....

And he's not very good.

All good except the Trengove trade proposal was supposedly put forward by Richmond not by Melbourne. I can't see it as being a complicated trade scenario designed by Melbourne,

Not a fair comparison. The upside on Jack we have seen . Its good. Jordie we have also seen his best and it ain't good.

Maybe, because the deal as proposed doesn't stack up for mine...