jnrmac

If you watch the video its in there..

Wow. What a post. He was the [censored] cause of the doldrums.

The umpire review agrees they cost us two goals on Friday night. The garland holding the ball and the Jay Kennedy Harris incident where he had his legs taken out from under him. I reckon they could add about three that Richmond got in front of goal as well.... Add that to the five posters and we would have beaten the toiges by a lot more. We'd be in the eight..... http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/wayne-campbell-admits-players-leading-with-their-head-into-tackles-is-biggest-issue-facing-umps/story-fni5f22o-1227324540885

What a great trade for Bernie. A great Roos deal. (cue perennial whingers) But of course it was melbourne's fault for not developing Col.....

Your psuedo intellectual arguments don't impress me nor do they hold water. As for the phrases you mentioned above - the second of which you claimed not to understand - they refer to someone with a holier than thou attitude such as the attitude you have been inflicting on those of us reading this topic. Your opinion is simply that. Your opinion. As for your statement that you "left the people concerned in no uncertain terms that what they said was wrong and inappropriate. 'All it takes for evil to prevail in this world is for enough good men to do nothing'" It is pathetic moral grandstanding at its worst. If you are so concerned about this why don't you head off to Lakemba and let Sheikh Hilaly know what you think of his 'Australian women are uncovered meat' sermon. Then you make an analogy with Judaism and have the audacity to respond to someone else's post with "Making spurious analogies do not aid or add efficacy to the debate". Pot Kettle black. The fact that you do not even recognise Jewish people as having a religion of their choice is plainly wrong and shows that you simply confuse what is racial vilification and what it legally means in this country. If you want to believe that our supreme leader is a little green man in an orange suit I couldn't care less. Just don't try and foist your views on me and claim you are being racially vilified when I and many others laugh at you. And claim to stand on the moral high ground where everyone around you is wrong.

Judaism is a choice not a race. Like every religion. Just because you are born a mormon doesn't mean you have to be a mormon once you are an adult. Do gooders like you blur the lines between what racial vilification actually is.

How is the view from your high horse?

This point Racial vilification is the term in the legislation of Australia that refers to a public act that encourages or incites others to hate people because of their race, nationality, country of origin, colour or ethnic origin.

That's his job,. To get the player the most he can. We had better learn to live with it even though we don't like it.

Good to see grimes making 9 tackles. Kudos for his effort and team ethic

I'm with you except for the bit about giving him two more years. He was recruited in the 2009 draft. This is his SIXTH year at the club. Can take a grab but I also don't see what the hype is about. If he hasn't cut it by now he is never going to. We need to play him or move him on.

I make it nine.

What 'race' is a Muslim?

Worked for Essendon. Drugs? What drugs? "We don't know what we took but we know they weren't illegal." He may well be a terrorist. How would we know?

Ouch SNAP.

Hmm in their salary cap like GWS???? I smells a rat. Adelaide got off lightly with their CEO and their cheating the salary cap. Should be an investigation.......

These comparisons with a king hit or coward punch are ludicrous. A king hit is when a person is hit and is completely unawares that it is happening. It is usually from behind. Have you people even seen the footage (which is edited and sendt to media outlets by the lager louts). The guy is lucky he is still walking the streets, I hope is charged.

The guy had been following him verballing him for 40m, Clarko pushed him away and the guy comes right back in his face, Who knows what the drunken clown was going to do. Those who are preaching that he should have walked on and ignored him are way off the mark. Clarko can be a tool sometimes but this time he was well within his rights.

6 Jones 5 VDB 4 Hogan 3 Garland 2 TMac 1. Jamar

Garland played a beauty actually. Have been waiting to see how he would go this year. Didn't like at all how he performed last year. Very pleased if he continues like that all year.

Which shows you why the award is a crock of shiite. Just vote on it at the end of the year regardless of who gets the gong each week.

No1. He is getting the ball No 2. He is trying to take the game on Yes he is getting caught a bit but it is the nature of where he plays. Its hot in the clinches and he will improve. Still young. Still learning. Huge upside to him. You want him to be taking the game on. Most of the best mids do that. They don't immediately dish off a handball. A lot to like about Dom.

And Ross left the Saints in tatters so there is a fair chance he will have not managed the list properly again...

In fact, with the appalling umpiring and the 5 posters we should have won by another 6-8 goals.

Well prior to the game he had not been beaten in a one on one this year nor had a goal kicked on him. He is in the reigning AA team. Its a fair scalp for a three gamer.