Jump to content

jnrmac

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by jnrmac

  1. jnrmac replied to ding's topic in Melbourne Demons
    If Melbourne wanted martin we could afford martin. There are all sorts of ways to engineer a salary package. Reading between the lines I'd say that the pay he was looking for(going by media reports) is well over what we think he is worth and so they wont make the effort to try and fit him in. As for Carlton - if they wanted to tie up $1.5m for Papley and Martin they have rocks in their head.
  2. I think picks can get traded up to and including draft night so I wouldn't expect a deal today....
  3. Maybe they could get Garlett back....
  4. Gold. I'll have whatever it is you're taking....
  5. But the "brilliant" assistant coaches have all been punted or been forced to change their role....
  6. Says a lot that a guy with zero trade value finishes in our top 10 B&F
  7. Good to see Oscar got a vote
  8. Cant afford him
  9. Seems these camp thingies can do a bit of damage....(cough*cough*)
  10. Not even close and you know it
  11. Hawks have (or will) used 50 for Patton. How TF do they get away with this. 50 for Patton 54 for Scully. Both former no 1 picks. Un-**********Believable.
  12. Surely at this point we need the best quality player we can get. Hopefully our down year is a one off (!) and we need to maximise the advantage that brings at the draft, As someone said earlier I am a bit sick of swapping picks with the Giants to see them run off with the cream
  13. Just like when Essendon wanted Oliver..:)
  14. If only......
  15. His 2018 form suggests he would stand up easily. Was rarely beaten and was an offensive weapon. We always overate our list generally- particularly when it comes to A/B graders - but the fact he has him bracketed with Stretch and Wagner shows that he has no clue about our list really.
  16. "For a team that has had so many top draft picks......" "The Demons haven’t had a first-round draft pick since 2015 when it picked Oliver at No.4 and Weideman at No.9...." Speaking of inconsistency..
  17. Harmes a C grader is BS. More like B to B+. Improved Consistency and he could be an A grader
  18. jnrmac replied to dave's topic in Melbourne Demons
    If I was a player looking to bump up my salary I would tell my manager to speak with Norf. They'll offer ridiculous money which you then take back to your club and say 'see what I am worth?' Kind of like what Elliott did to us.......
  19. Its more about endurance - you need some speed but the ability to run up and down all day is more important IMO. And he can mark which gives us two down the line options with max.
  20. The Bell end knows that Langdon is out of contract and can go to the draft. If hes being nice thats the only reason. It's a toss up between him and DerWayne as to who is the biggest jerk.
  21. He can take a grab. I think his numbers for marking are elite. So if he is on the wing we have a very interesting set up with Max and he taking down the line marks. That should help us enormously. I like the comparison above - like TMac but with better disposal.
  22. Elliott is hopeless anyway.... ha ha
  23. My understanding he was told to take the game on but give the ball off to the first option - ie don't try to be too fancy. In that regard he has mostly stuck to the plan. He has been used to take on the Buddy's or Danihers in the past but perhaps may is now that option and so the uses for Frosty are more limited. I read somewhere that Tomlinson is being touted as a winger but for mine Frosty could play that role quite well. Certainly better than Jones or Lewis like we did in 2019!
  24. Someone hack your account?