JACKATTACK

I'm confused about the FS rule. The rule says if another club chooses to nominate Viney with their first selection it forces Melbourne to use its "next available" selection. Knowing that we have already committed ourselves to Viney what is stopping a club with a pick ahead of us nominating him, forcing us to take him with our first pick? Also, do our compo picks count as 'next available', and what if we choose to trade all our top picks away? Can we then force our 'next available' to be very late? AFL FS RULE

I would be super excited if we got him, he certainly has talent.

Now that i think about it Scully had a sensational 2011; should win our B&F easily.

Agreed; almost as one sided as the triple M commentry for the day.

MFC could do with a Matthews, if only for his leadership

That's true but you can hardly expect someone to read through the 50,000 odd posts about TS to check each rumour. That would just be cruel.

Act now, fold the club.

I would be content with Eade, a coach who beats him will have to be pretty good.

Get him. He is exacty what we need, someone who can take a contested mark from in front. I watched the hawks game and was getting a bit annoyed that he was playing well, Port's asking price for him would have doubled. I would be extremely dissapointed if Melbourne wasn't on the front foot for a player like this. I'm sure he'd be keen to get out of Port.

If I were Melbourne I'd be offering Blease overs to stay. Guaranteed GWS are

Great news!

Time to change banks.

I don't normally tip Melbourne, especially against top 4 teams. But this week i'm tipping them, just because if we do win I can say I tipped them. Go Dees.

Or just add $500,000 into the coach poach kitty.

Works for me!

As an assistant certainly.

Supporters with important prior engagements and those under 10 years old are excused. Everyone else should be there. EDIT: Including you stranga. Disolusionment, while understandable is no reason to bail. I'm not going for the players, the board and certainly not the administration. I'm not even going for Jimmy. Just the colours.

So should every Melbourne supporter with anything more than a pea heart. And wear the colours, because that is about the only thing I can support at the moment.

I'd be chasing Butcher, right age, has talent (or at least did have talent) and wants to return to Vic.

HUN says: is tall, can run And aparently we can add Grimes to our list of rucks as well!! Must have had one hell of a growth spurt.

Best wishes and all the luck and strength in the world.

Watts: The great white fear. Is he tough enough? This will be the most argued point on demonland for the next 5 years.