Cheap Seats

I know Ricky is a [censored] of the highest order but god i hope we are throwing the kitchen sink at Menegola. I rekon BB is a done deal TMac is interesting, i am still amazed anyone would trade for him with what he is contracted for.... but stranger things have happened. Most of it is fluff as Ricky is a born salesman, but that Menegola rumour has me very excited.

I get your point, but I am not asking for fait accompli information, I am interested if there is anything @Demons11 has heard around the traps

Wow, would be a decent pick up for the dogs. Any other info you're heading @demons11. Any word on Brodie Smith? or other tid bits you got? I am assuming our moves will be based on if Tmac stays or goes?

Thanks for the updates. Must admit i am slightly excited for some change.

I think we need speed and class. Not really sure Phillips is that player.

Thanks for the info Any other news to report? Or nothing solid?

Agree. As much as i dislike the Cats you can't deny they are a well run organisation and will get the job done.

No matter what happens with GWS matching i guarantee you there is ZERO chance Geelong would back down from their commitment to Cameron.

Edited for accuracy

Any details of what didnt go well?

Ia ot possible the numbers are the front ended amount and not the total contract per year?

There can be a lot of reasons. Sometimes managers wont talk to clubs and the clubs get the idea pretty quickly... Sometimes there are also other reasons.

Turns out he's not playing with them either.

Unless he's (smith) has signed a hoa or on the dotted line it's never final, things can change. But in saying that you are right until he's in the polo it's not official. Fun times, i dont know why people get upset with this stuff. Better to have something to talk aboit rather than none at all. Also on tom morris surely the cats must have some retirements coming. How the fek do they fit in Cameron, Higgins and smith with the mature list they already have.

Whether you're right or wrong time will tell. You'll either be Dr. evil or Dr No. Always a fun time of year. Thanks for sharing regardless

I suppose you also think that Lethal and Dunstall were bad appointments at the Lions/Hawks boards respectively. I'm not saying Green will be a good appointment but wowee wot a load of pointless drivel.

Why bother posting if you're just going to whinge and make non factual statements? Is there a dumbass award I'm not aware of on here?

Is be amazed if anyone traded for him.

I reckon its because the AFL and AFLPA have to work out list sizes and pay, its holding up a lot of player/clubs decisions. Hence why it's so quiet....

There was an early runor getting around we coule be in to leppistch. Would be massive if true.

This vid has stitched a few ppl up in recent times. That's a comedia/impersonator not the real G Abblett

I reckon James Hird was clearly our biggest drafting blunder. Jackovic seriously hardly played for us.

Swanny is still upset that Oliver doesn't think he's cool. #Swannytryingtostayrelavent

Aww im sorry i upset you. Please continue whinging

So above you're talking TPP and that wasnt the point. And again we have no idea how the contract would structured. It could be front loaded and he could end up plsy ing for minimums plus incentives for 2 of the 3 years. Would you say Smith is more valuable then say a pick 50 then? But the point made by Moonshadow was contract length anf not terms. Contact have multiple ways they can be broken, including retirement, mutual agreement and dismissal. The whole length term argument for smith is irrelevant. You either want a more talented list or you don't. Lets not pretend recruiting Smith is going to hurt the club, He comes across for free and helps the club one way or another. The rest is irrelevant for a lots of reasons which cant be debated because we simply wouldn't know terms of the agreement.