Jump to content

whatwhat say what

Life Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by whatwhat say what

  1. i want a best 22 player given the dotage of may and plugger mac: keane holds appeal - he apaz wants to return to the filth - as a tall defender aged under 25 jordan butts is vic lad who is also a solid tall defender their mids are for the most part, mid - soligo, chayce jones, lachlan sholl, harry schoenberg (albeit the latter is an sa boy) their push up small forwards who anb will replace are meh - lachie murphy, ned mchenry, lachie gollant... keane or butts for mine`
  2. yah, i figure peter wright got 4 so it's probably that
  3. if keane wants to leave adelaide to go back to the city of melbourne, i wonder whether he could be part of the package for nibbs? would allow us to leave petty - jvr - turner as three key forwards, with keane the replacement for plugger mac and, eventually, may i must admit i'd rather a player than a pick for nibbs
  4. flagmantle a chance of dropping out with both baggers and dingley to make it both have two to play and are on 48 with significantly better % than the filth they both win one of their two remaining games - with the latter likely to win both against the teams bottom of the ladder given their red hot form, while baggers should be capable of beating one of meth coke or the aints - and they jump to 52 with better % than filth can likely climb to unless they beat us by 100+ with us scoring less than 42 points or something like that i can't see filth making it better beat em anyway just to be on the safe side
  5. sheezel + wardlaw + the picks they used to trade up to duursma not bad
  6. flagmantle vulnerable to drop out, but filth would need to make up significant percentage to get ahead of them, dingley, or the baggers hard to see it happening
  7. filth just won't say die
  8. no thanks; can't stand that franchise if bloods don't win the premiership then they'll have wasted one of the most dominant years a club can have meanwhile, bears should've won at least one in the fagan era
  9. 6: viney 5: langdon 4: mcdonald 3: turner 2: petty 1: gawn
  10. 9 goal win by a side who have been under the pump all week vs a team that have made their home deck a fortress and who were missing one of their best 23 players fantastic to watch
  11. once again, var messes with us
  12. the king bros are bog ordinary - no efforts
  13. no questioning viney's cultural contributions
  14. ainsworth is the only 'good' player missing from this gc17 line-up they really are pathetic
  15. people criticising kolt need their heads read it ain't a day for clean skills, and his effort and workrate is top notch
  16. petty worked the breeze to perfection
  17. imo gc17 are pathetic - that they have had access to so much talent over the course of their time and they still haven't got near finals is an indictment upon them as a franchise these sides very much look like teams who are sitting 11-13 on the ladder
  18. i still don't think he should be playing
  19. miss his handball to jvr for a goal? he's stopped his man rebounding from defence too
  20. peter jackson didn't think so - at least not yet
  21. pert always presents well in the media he knows how to massage the narrative - be at at the mfc, the cfc, or sca but there's a difference between massaging the narrative and managing the circumstances that have led to it
  22. ...made sense given their form in the back half of this season...
  23. didn't he just sign a contract extension?
  24. fify i thought the grundy acquisition was a risk, but a risk worth taking - another example of the club not being prepared to simply sit back and NOT try something different they way i see it, we effectively had him as a 'loan' for a year it was a risk, it didn't work move on
  25. crazy that flagmantle, baggers, peptides are all fighting for the last spot in the 8