Beamer

Bartram - Had no impact Bell - Tried but lost Bruce - Worked hard Buckley - Was shut down Carroll - Wasnt to bad Frawley - Learn to kick Garland - Did the job Green - A courageous performance Grimes - Some nice touches Holland - Never gave up Jones - Never had impact McDonald - Not his best Maric - Beaten by opponent Miller - Tried but failed Morton - Had no poise Petterd - Good first half Sylvia - Reliable all day Warnock - Played very well Wheatley - No work ethic Whelan - Battled hard White - Good farewell effort Yze - Prolific but ineffective

Basically I think the structure was very poor. Apart from Miller, our main targets when entering the forward 50 were Maric and Sylvia. Both simply not the players to do the job required.

I thought there were a few positives from the game. Ricky Petterds first half, Positive signs. Jack Grimes did some good things, needs to hit the gym along with Morton. Warnock was impressive and will be a real general down back next season. Colin Sylvia was fantastic today and should hit some excellent consistent form next year after he does a full pre-season.

I thought Petterd was excellent til injury. His work ethic was great and found lots of the footy. Many positives, just got to get his body right now.

6. Sylvia - Battled hard. 5. Warnock - Did the job. 4. Bruce - Worked hard. 3. White - Good farewell effort. 2. Green - Courageous. 1. Whelan - Never gave in. Carroll deserves an honourable mension. I thought he was OK today.

Good trait bait is Clint Bartram.

Moloney wont be of much trade value due to injury. Same circumstances as Rivers. So I would keep him, Dynamic player on his day. After hearing that next years draft will be raped by GC17, the chance of getting a top 15 pick for Brad Green is dramatically decreasing. So I would like to see him sign up. Bell can go. Anything inside the Top 40 would be a good trade. Too Dunn, hes done some good shut down jobs but is too much of a one dimensional player.

I mean continue regading the couple of players you are not thanking for pulling on the Sandy jumper. Anyway, I will stilll like to see you around here. Even though we wont be affiliating with Sandy, Ill be taking an outside interest in their progression.

Thanks for your generous post. Continue though?

Went back to basics with this. What does everyone think?

Im going to have a crack at something with version A.

Interestingly, does anyone think theres a chance we wont pick Watts, Naitinui or Rich. I think Ziebell will be the pick of the lot in years to come. At the moment hes just not as well developed as Rich.

Thats a neat looking list. Add the pace of Davey through there and Wheatleys precision skills sometimes. Its a nice combination.

Good player over a long period. Ability to suddenly have an impact when under-done or out of form was amazing. Thanks & Good luck.

Doubt you'd ever hear Rhino conceed defeat. Hes Mr.Perfect.

Could come down to the wire.

I think theyre going to try Carroll in the ruck. Hence the dropping of Jamar. I know White is there but yes. Cant wait to see Grimes in action at AFL level.

Whats the good of putting senior players on the market. Every team needs some senior boys, experience is ever so important when building a young team.

Take that any day of the year mate.

The words Mighty & Bolton should never be used in the same sentence. Back on topic, I've made a vote and its A. Just for the fact that it brings back our identity as the Demons.

Doesnt make sense. I dont want anyone to bid for him?

A would look good with an improved Demon, or even the one from last year.

We wont get anything worthy for him. Its worth keeping him cause if he gets past his injuries, he will return to the fantastic form of his first 2 years.

CJ, Green & Pick 19 for Rob Warnock and Fremantles first pick? Never going to happen

Keep Riv. Other deal sounds OK, but do we need another so-so midfielder?