picket fence

I agree that Brendan Mc Cartney was instrumental in Clarries last couple of years. He still finds the ball but why does he persist in this jockeying for position with another player is beyond me. Does Danger do it does Dusty. I reckon if this is a coach driven thing it is flawed logic, Surely he can stand more or less by himself and let MAX Palm it out.!? I was frustrated that time and again he needed to jostle and bounce of someone, surely the idea is to keep moving with a set strategy for palm outs??

Oh God now you are sounding like Dan apologists! Of Course Simon Says!!

Agree MASSIVE FAILS in Goodwins Tenure!

John Dellamarta, Wayne Gordon, Charlie Pagnocolo??

Clarry Choo Choo would do well to aspire to the Lofty standards of a Dangerfield!! Sadly, unless Miracles occur, I cannot see it under Goodwins Regime!!

Well yes and no!Not that I want to sit on the fence!?

Just like any other day on Demonland!!?

He kicks goals.... something not a lot of our guys know how to do. For all I care he can wear pink boots, colored nail varnish and have more makeup than Marilyn Manson sing "The real thing" each time he kicks a major and wear his hair any God damn way he likes providing he kicks goals which he seems to be able to do!! Regularly!! Get him in! And when we get him in he will develop a CULT Following! Starting with me!

T Mac goes as part of the deal,, Oh and Oscar can go with him!! Those 2018 highlights offer COMPELLING evidence that he is not just a lead up forward. DEES GET THIS DONE FFS

Nah.. Dennis LILLEE had a HUUUUUGE RUN UP and he went orright!! ?

Champion player just breathtaking!

This is true, However, any other club would be putting time in to assess how big an offer it would take to lure him away! There would be clubs out there I'm sure that would offer him around $850 -$ 900 Grand or more per year for 5 years. Now if that is the case can you see MFC being able to match that??

I want to put this to rest. We cannot accept anything for Clarry!! Period!! And I say this If we have signed up Viney for 5 years to the detriment of getting Oliver for the same amount of time then that's me Done totally with MFC FOREVER!!

I want to put this to rest. We cannot accept anything for Clarry!! Period!! And I say this If we have signed up Viney for 5 years to the detriment of getting Oliver for the same amount of time then that's me Done totally with MFC FOREVER!!

Well if you are correct and this is compensation for losing Captaincy, then.... We are worse of than I first thought!

BANG!

Good! he can take Melksham's spot on a HFF

Ok, because you have put money into a limited footballer with the potential of little to no improvement. His game has not evolved from day 1 1 Tries to take on player after player after player and more often than not gets caught or is panicked into a poor disposal. 2 Will not honour the first option, or second 3 Kicking is adequate but not elite 4 No Right side 5 Too one dimensional. 6 What if ... His foot injuries return? Ok thats my take on WHY this decision will bite us. IMV Take it or leave it! Ok over to you, can you give me 5 Compelling reasons for a 5 year deal???

Unless the vote givers have blinkers on! As I put up his stats for the year previously compared to Oliver in fact I would say his year was nowhere near a 3 rd in B&F ! Go on check his stats for yourself. I and other rated Oliver as easily 3rd in B & F. 2 years would have been enough with clear trigger for a third. 5 years for Viney? Unbelievable!

Ok Got it

Good onya Wayne, so I'm not entitled to a reasoned opinion??

And what is that reason???

No, bookmark my comment coz I reckon this decision will come back and bite BIG TIME!

1 possibly 2 year deal with triggers. Bookmark this for same time next year and see if I'm mistaken!

LOL