BScotti

I may be proved incorrect here, but when he signed his last contract it was also reported he was unhappy with direction and he and his manager met with the club to ensure he got more midfield time as he didnt want to play primarily fwd. Media got hold of that too and said he might go... I just think thats the way he and his manager rolls. Not great for club , but I dont think he is going anywhere.

Cameron Bruce? Currently at Brisbane as midfield coach

2025 Trade / list changes - Hypothetical only - TMac or Tomlinson - If Tmac retites, Tommo stays. If TMac plays on Tommo is gone - Loved Luke Hodge suggestion for MFC to chase Ben King and offer big money. While I like it, I think that would be very hard to do, however, Id be more inclined to chase Mac Andrew - will have a soft spot for Dees given NGA connection and could get deal done - with 1 yr to go on contract - Gone - Schache, Joel Smith, BBB, KFW, Gus - Bring in Houston and Edwards - Bring in a Mid (like Robertson) - DRAFT - new NGA to replace KFW and Yze onto Rookie

Really interesting to see what happens this week at selection, given Goody's "full bore" comment yet unable to make finals and opportunity to start pre-season early for some carrying injuries, and others needing an opportunity. Does he try something new for last 2 weeks or stay with current plan. I would think this is an opportunity to try something.... Jefferson? Ruck support? Clarry to go in for op and start preseason? Ben Brown farewell?

I don't think he had any real preseason and got injured early in season so was behind eight ball and looked unfit. lets see what full preseason does for him, Clarry, Spargo, Salem......

2025 version of Jack Watts

after what Goody said about Fullerton after Freo game, there is no chance he can play him this year.

good player stuck behind some guns. would be a good get and some class.

going to throw a left field idea here.... all the talk is Waterman as a big body KFP. If we look at it, we would seek such a move for a big fwd target for a few more years as JVR, Jeffo etc further develop. as an alternative, and not dissimilar (but probably more reliable), what about Sam Day from GC who is off contract and we offer him 3 years. we will probably only get 2 out of him but big body, can mark, can kick and not getting run on GC over King, and youth. maximise our window

Out of frustration and a reminder of hope and opportunity, I watched the 21 GF replay, and a couple of things really stood out to me: - The unexpected loss of both Jackson and Gus significantly hurt us structurally, and was/is a huge dent in our planning for long term success and list management. Its not like you can just flick a switch to replace those two. - Add to that the injury this year to Tracs and to a lesser extent delivery from Spargo, and our structure and balance has seriously been thrown out. - Give Clarry a full preseason to get back to where he was prior to this season. - The importance of #1 FWD in BBB was critical to balance, however his early deterioration of his knees also offset our balance and plans a couple of years early. - I remain excited about the work put into the kids on the squad, and the opportunity for a sustainable rebound however with the two major losses it probably shortened our window unless we can be creative with new experienced additions, given we wont have the same draft capital available as we need to replace, especially given the age profile of our stars - we no longer have the same time period. - So as I see it our priorities remain: 1. Ruck support for Max - not back up ruck playing at Casey, actual capable ruck/fwd playing regularly in best 22 "in LJ style". requires a tweak to Goody current plan and gets back to what worked for us. Im not saying we have to go out and get it, but perhaps its Verral/Fullo now and look to draft our next Ruck. 2. Rebound defender/class mid user - Gus role was so important as it supported defence but gave us a qulaity mid and fwd delivery option which we have lost. So the need to further support Lever/May and while Riv has/can play that role, someone like a Houston is probably a really good fit to complement. Given I presume Tomlinson will see the light and leave seeing its clear Goody has no role for him (other than break glass in case of emergency), + see 4 below. 3. Strong Key Fwd to take #1 defender, to allow growth of JVR and Jeffo next year and remove pressure of Fritch and Melk who are not contested fwd's and can be freed up. Someone like a Waterman would be good for the time we need him. BBB filled that role beautifully until his knees gave out. 4. Petty to go back to defence where he was so strong and in his element. I thought it ironic in the commentary of GF21 where they said, "Petty has been amazing since coming for the injured Tomlinson and has not missed a beat". He is a defender - play him primarily as a defender with the ability to swing on a case by case basis. I presume also TMac wont have another year as strong as he did this year. Petty can take his place and TMac can play the Jonesey role on a game by game basis and educate the defenders coming through. 5. Midfield depth required. Targets on horizon - Mac Andrew (Trade target), Kalani White (draft target), Dev Robertson (trade)

Embarrassing by the club, selection committee, but most importantly the coach. The way Goody hung Fullerton out to dry in the press conference was really poor form and nothing but trying to divert attention away from himself.. I think they used him as a scape goat as they admitted we would lose the hit outs before the game started. That's weak. Rather than trying to be competitive (and even is he did think we would lose, what a learning experience for TF). Instead, we hung the kid out to dry in the press, went in with 2 makeshift rucks, against arguably the best 1 -2 ruck combo in the comp and a highly effective and efficient midfield who are in form. Petty and JVR were both playing out of position, one whom we are trying to make our key forward and wonder why we got smashed in clearances. All of this because of poor selection decisions. Goody just admit you got it wrong.

Deciphering "Goody speak".......I would not be confident if I was Tom Fullerton.

surely if Max needs an in game rest and we want JVR to stay as a fwd then we need 2nd ruck. It is the reason we traded for Fullerton. However if we dont use him soon it will be too late in the season to test it. Out - Turner, Woewodin In - Petty, Fullerton

Goody gave nothing directly at the presser today re team selection however reading between the Goody lines, it sounds like: In - Salem, Bowey, Melk Out - Petty (inj), ?? normally is a newbie was to debut they would have mentioned it so I am guessing no Jeffo.

do i go complete conspiracy theory and suggest the "North" in Nth Melbourne has some link to a potential new team in NT? not saying relocate but....

Petty and a 1st rounder for Tilthorpe Charlie Cameron on the way out of Brisbane - Freo the talk. Cameron and Kossie at the feet of JVR and Tilthorpe - yes pls Roberston would be good (if we cant get LDU) . Dees liked him in draft year. Cameron and Robertson for ?

Fritta out - Fullerton in (against old side and double team Big O and free JVR up) Bowey Out - Woewodin in (only if Salem is ok) Howes out - Lever in (Tomlinson to Howes role) Chandler to sub, Pup Jnr full game

that means, if he plays, Petty stays fwd. Goody stubborn..

I just dont get why we brought him in then if we are not giving him an opportunity to play in the role he was brought in for. This is a guy who kicked 7 goals for the Lions AFL team when called on due to injuries. We need a reliable fwd/ruck - thats why we got him. JVR can play KPF and work on his craft. Clearly not a Goody fav....

Bowey May McVee Petty Tmac Salem Langdon Sparrow Windsor Fritsch Fullerton Neal Bullen McAdam JVR Pickett Gawn Oliver Viney Rivers Woewodin Turner Howes Chandler

i just hope Goody does something different. Definition of insanity....doing same thing wanting a different result.

this focus Goodwin had of trying to find defenders and turn them into forwards and they end up doing neither well. Turner and Petty are lost in those positions. No idea. Delivery to them is horrible. No forward craft by anyone. Goodwin new game plan is horrendous.

can anyone shed light as to why Fullerton was replaced as an emergency for AFL but did not play VFL?

Since the loss of Jacko, we have been trying to find a 2nd ruck / fwd (not fwd who we ask to ruck). They could not get their head around Grundy (he was pure ruck) and now they traded for Fullerton for this role. 10 rounds in we still have not played him. This band aid philosophy including defender Petty to fwd is clearly not working. BBB is done. Billings is ok around the ground but get him anywhere near the goals and he is a "dear in the headlights". Send him back as a HFF and get him some confidence. Petty to defence to play a system and get hands on the ball. Play fwd as a fwd, ruck as a ruck and def as a def. Keep it simple. Out - BBB, Lever, Billings, IN - JVR, Fullerton, Langdon

perfect game this week to bring in McAdam and Fullerton and let them do what they were drafted for.