Swooper1987

Was lucky enough to know Robbie for a short time through his involvement in SEDA. He gave me this in 2009 for my 40th birthday. I recall telling him I wore his number as a kid on my MFC jumper back in the late 70's, early 80's. The most humble champion I ever met.

This 100%. There'd be nobody more qualified in the country than Ponissi to pass judgement on effective leadership in sport. Watson is a very astute operator. Always balanced and with vast experience dating back to Sheedy. Nothing wrong at all with the panel. And the process reached a pretty logical decision given Buckley's stance re Tasmania. It's a good appointment.

https://www.goldcoastfc.com.au/video/1395431/rd21-king-post-match?videoId=1395431&modal=true&type=video&publishFrom=1691221097001

Remember him breaking Jeff White's face in the 2005 elim final.

Your point is valid. There is, however, a longer list of first time coaches who disappeared into the abyss. Here's some names from relatively recent times - Brisbane - Voss, Leppitsch Carlton - Brittain, Ratten, Bolton, Teague Essendon - Knights, Hird, Rutten North - Shaw, Noble (Laidley and Scott did make finals) Melbourne - Bailey, Neeld Gold Coast - McKenna, Dew St Kilda - Watters, Richardson West Coast - too early to tell on McQualter Fremantle - have gone both ways and the only really successful was Lyon who got them to a granny who was a second timer. Otherwise they've gone first timers throughout their history which is now 30 years without saluting. GWS have only had first timers since Sheedy and both Cameron and Kingsley have been relatively successful. Most of the rest have had good stability for a decent period - Geelong Thompson/Scott; Hawthorn Clarkson/Mitchell; Swans - Roos/Longmire/Cox It's easy to get it wrong with a first timer. Of the second or third timers currently - Voss - prelim Lyon - finals in first year then a reset Clarkson - nothing yet Brad Scott - nothing yet Hardwick - finals

I think they got it right this year, unlike last year. If you average Tracc and Pickett's votes per game, Koz beats him, but those three games missed cost him runner up. Tracc had a decent season. Pleased Bowey finished top 5 and Salem was consistent and pretty reliable. As for Max, he should have 5 of these (robbed in 2016 and 2024). What a champion he is.

Ghosty, do you know if they are streaming it tonight? Doesn't seem to be anything on the website or the app.

Didn't he already get it as premiership coach? If not he should have.

1 Max- ripped off last year, couldn't possibly lose this year 2 Tracc - a pretty consistent year - didn't miss a game, polled coaches votes in 10 games 3 Kozzy - deserved AA year 4 Bowey - slowed towards the end but strong start and good middle should see him finish high 5 Gets harder from here but Chin, Clarry, Disco, Melky, Salem all around about 5-10

Is this on tomorrow night (9/9)? I received an email from the club a while back but have heard nothing since. Usually they run a preview on the club website.

Sean Charles was quick

Daisy Thomas talking sense though. Buckley is a realist. If he goes to Tasmania he's not winning a flag. Small town club, playing in front of 15-20k for home games and not much better than that away, and at least 5 years before they'd be genuinely competitive. Melbourne - the MCG most weeks, big games like ANZAC eve and King's Birthday, already competitive and with great young talent. At 53 the clock is ticking for that elusive premiership. It's not a difficult choice.

I generally stay away from these topics but I see Buckley as being so much better prepared this time around. 10 years of experience at Collingwood including 5 years of finals, three consecutive from 18-20 (GF, Prelim and semi), finished up half way through 21. Had Nick Daicos been born four years earlier, Buckley is at least a one time, and quite possibly two time premiership coach. If you go back and look at the team that took the field for Collingwood in 2018 it's a miracle they got as close to WCE as they did. His analysis is impressive and he has a gravitas in the footy community that we really need. Gawn has been a great front man but ideally the coach does that job. Buckley is a media heavyweight. I think he will reinvigorate Petracca and Oliver and should he be appointed I expect both will stay.

Just did a quick check of Wheelo's page and found that only three players this season polled coaches votes in 16 games - two from Gold Coast (Rowell and Miller) and Gawn. What an extraordinary achievement in a team that only won 7 times. That is consistency of a remarkable level.

He's now certainly the greatest ruck of all time. Having followed the Demons since the late 70's as a very young kid, the only player who would rival Max in my time would be Flower. Petracca and Oliver from the recent era are both champions but never had the influence of Gawn. Neitz, Lyon and Stynes are rightfully Hall Of Fame members but again, none could do what Max has done. He's an all time great and future AFL Legend.