Dr.D

what are u talking about? he missed 2 simple shots, 1 hard shot and his only goal was from the goal square. he didn't provide any forward pressure that I noticed.

most important game for the year? you've got to be kidding? The game of the year was vs Sydney and then consequently Freo. These games are meaningless.We can't make finals unless some big upsets happen.

a real shame that we've missed finals. no chance the dogs lose the last 2 games. we've got no-one but ourselves and Goodwin to blame for that.

wrong. he has this trend in his game which is very costly. it costs us every week. I'm always yelling at him to get rid of the bloody ball and he just gets into more and more trouble. stupid footballer that tries hard. trade or delist

[censored] off to the cats viney! how many times are you going to be done for holding the ball! get rid of the [censored] ball u goose!

Oliver won't return.

I agree that he is so [censored] thst he must be injured. I can reel off probably 100 forwards in country and the amateur leagues that are currently better than Tom McDonald. he is so far beneath the standard.

And last season? what's next season's excuse? we've got one of the healthiest lists in the comp. no excuses for this rabble of a season.

Yeah. he is a ruck, not a forward and I don't think we can carry 3 talls in our forward line with the poor crumbers that we have. We can't rely on pickett or Spargo to even find the footy, let alone kick goals.

tell me. how are Hogan and Peter Wright going to help with our forward pressure. They're just as slow as McDonald.

correct. which is why mihocek would be chosen before LJ

if we keep viney, then brayshaw needs to go. I'm sick of our inside miss having no awareness and getting in each other's way. As soon as an inside mid doesn't have the ball he becomes an outside mid. They have to start understanding this principle and respecting spacing, and defensive accountability.

i'm sorry but Luke Jackson isn't a forward. he is a ruck.

im so happy that he didn't work out at Freo after Peter Bell's antics during the trade period. Karmas a biatch. I'd take him back but I wouldn't give up anything for him. Makes our defensive stuff even worse. And he doesn't bring positivity to a group.

Why do people even want to make finals? Do people think you get a trophy for coming 8th and losing first round? we lost to Sydney and Fremantle. convincingly. I'd prefer to lose the next 2 games so change occurs.

who cares? he hasn't been good anyway. we need speed and he offers as much speed as a fat record boy

Have you not been watching us? we're 10th, and the way we've been playing we're a big chance to lose the final 2 games. So that puts us about 12th. Following on from 17th last year. And that's with no injuries this year! We won't be so lucky next year. If Goodwin stays, how can you think that we're not bottom 4 next year? McDonald is cooked, Melksham is cooked, Brayshaw is as slow as he's ever been, Viney may leave, Pickett hasn't showed anything, Jackson is a ruckman playing forward until Gawn is done, Fritsch is now without a position as his goal kicking has let him down, Lever is still shaky in defence. Please don't try and sell hope.

Why are people even talking about Papley and Zac Williams. The last 2 weeks has shown us that we're probably going to be a bottom 4 team next year. We need to start rebuilding. Take the viney compensation and nail the draft pick.

it's good. We're a [censored] club with basically no hope for the future. Especially with no picks, and our inside midfielders consistently running into each other and offering no outside spread. Viney is the worst in this regard. Trade and get the pick right.

who cares that's what I say. Against stkilda we were [censored], the bulldogs we were more [censored], versus Sydney we were even more [censored] and against Fremantle we were equally as [censored].

kozzie has been bloody gross the last month or so. He can't find the footy, he has no football IQ (this can't be underrated), and his skills are just so so.

oh, we don't have ours?

it's tough. pickett looks [censored] to me so id be looking for some more forward craft at the draft. luke Jackson looks great though. That's about it. Bedford, Baker, brown, omac, Jones can go. trade 1 of brayshaw or viney

6 tackles in a bloody quarter!! in the wet! bloody joke.

I don't give a [censored] anymore. no amount of good games will make up for last week's disgrace.