Dr.D

maybe do a ladder predictor and get back to me. 5th or even 6th isn't out of the question.

I'm usually the first one to pot the umpires but not this time. The game should've been over at half time no questions asked, but we slackened off for 10 mins and lost the game. That's on our players. Picture this, 3/4 time, our premiership hopes are on the line in terms of a top 4 finish. We recognise that we need to start winning more contests. So what happens at the first centre bounce in the last quarter? A straight forward centre clearance and kick to Lewis who strolls in to take the mark and goals. Enough said. It was a pea hearted effort by all players and coaches tonight.

It's because we haven't respected goal kicking accuracy all season or pre-season. We get what we deserve. Why hasn't Picketts routine been improved? He clearly doesn't kick with momentum. Why does Weideman often miss to the right? Why can Fritsch only be reliable snapping? Why does Mcdonald not allow enough space when snapping from a set shot and has had it smothered 3 times in 2 weeks?

You called me a troll when I said we'd finish 5th because you guys couldn't fathom the idea that we could finish 5th. I had done my research and I looked at all the teams and who they were playing and looked at our form and came up with 5th. So I've now proven that my prediction is the most accurate because you guys couldn't even stomach the idea that coming 5th was within the realms of possibility.

Same [censored] different week!! 1. Understanding of momentum in a game. We are 1 goal away from it being a landslide midway through the 2nd. But no. We switch off and allow hawthorn and run on and to enter half time full of confidence. Dumb. 2. Goal kicking; a lack of respect for the severity of misses and losing all chances of momentum and scoreboard pressure. 3. Clearances: Still not good enough. How was the first 10 seconds of the last quarter! Hawks breakaway from the middle with disgusting ease and goal. You'd think our top 4 chances weren't on the line or something! 4. Kicking to dangerous spots inside 50m. Stop kicking it to the bloody pockets. 20metres out directly in front and put their defenders under real pressure.

Viney: career worst form Players: drinking own bathwater. Goodwin: can't motivate players

All of you people talking about top 4 and top 2. I've proven you wrong time and time again! this is now proof. We are now unlikely to make the top 4. You are torturing yourselves by continuing to talk about top 2 and top 4 and have NO RESPECT for just how little you can trust this club. SHAME ON EVERYONE WHO SAID I WAS NEGATIVE JUST FOR STATING I BELIEVED WE WOULD FINISH 5TH. Since my comment, there has been numerous articles stating how we are at risk of losing that spot. And guess what, MORE ARE COMING! LESSON: NEVER EVER doubt my knowledge of this football team.

I'm sorry but when are people going to start realising that I speak the truth! This was a bloody disgrace and top 4 is out of the question now. Most likely playing richmond round 1. Good job guys!

u guys should block me coz im gonna come so hard for all the people that were talking about top 2/top 4 etc. despite a body of evidence that shows we have a soft underbelly.

who cares about the [censored] umpiring! that's what happens when we're second to the ball! lift melbourne u bunch of pretenders.

here's a thought. when a hawks player has his head over the ball, don't get him high. you dumb [censored]!

who gives a [censored] about these frees. if we actually dominate the game the ball won't even go into their forward line! lift ffs!!!

this is so bad. yet so typical. who to blame? players or coaches or both? this is one of the worst teams in the league. and in experienced. They have nothing to play for, we have everything.

Career worst form. Needs to be dropped soon unless he starts respecting the severity of a turnover. just kick it high to a 50/50. I'd rather that than lace out an opposition backman. hopeless.

players getting ahead of themselves and not respecting the opposition and just how quickly teams can score. very typical melbourne.

wake the [censored] up melbourne! kick it to dangerous spots in the fwd line. and Viney, stop being [censored]! Win by 50 or don't count it as a win. f$%^ing hopeless melbourne.

0.3. standard

all this talk again is way too premature. Do people realise that if we win 3 of the last 6. we will most likely be tied with 2 teams on points. And the lowest % misses out on top 4 altogether. Surely the losses against Collingwood, gws and Adelaide put people back in their box for a bit. We need to win the next 2 games, no questions.

Finally a post that recognises the importance of goal kicking accuracy

I think rain helps our contested brand but it also makes goal kicking more difficult, which we don't need. Time to switch on guys and much needed % is up for grabs. Take it and be ruthless. Surge the ball forward.

I literally said he'd be top 10 about a week ago. The Nik Cox evolution has probably helped Mac Andrews go up the board.

No need. I think I'm already that little voice in your head telling you to not get ahead of yourself. Objective complete.

How did I pot a fellow poster? That implies I potted him personally. So please show me where I did that. I await that. You're the only one who made it personal.

A little aggressive I would've thought. Pretty content actually :) I just perceive most posters as fanciful. It's like if you go and read another clubs forum. Half the stuff you read makes you laugh at how biased it is. I'm very even-keeled and am completely impartial. Maybe being slightly more critical than most, aka the way Gary Lyon sees Melbourne.

I give up. :) I've ruled out jumper numbers, spelling of names, tattoos, helmet wearers and hair colour.