Billy

[censored] off, umpiring criminal & playing Petty again cost us 0.4, he is sooo underwhelming We had a crack, some good young kids

GET PETTY OFF!!!!!!!!!!!

Harry Petty is a weak as water, absolutely weak

I disagree, we’re playing plenty of kids as it is, if he’s fit and firing he should absolutely play

Just think Clarry has copped enough negative press & disgusting comments from the AFL media & opposition supporters that we should stick fat with one of our own

Here here, we’ll said Favourite ever Demon & a hell of a good bloke as well

Why a different role??? He got 35 possessions against the Doggies round two, playing how Clarry has always played Contested ball, tackling & running full pace out of congestion dishing off & getting other players involved Thats how he became one of the top three players in the competition I don’t believe this stuff about his fitness, he’s had 15 weeks of competitive football, and now he’s losing fitness? Need just let him play the only way he knows Im sure he realises that he owes the club

The pile on that the MFC has received from the media this year is completely out of control & needs to stop. We are 8&6 fighting for a spot in the finals, you’d think we haven’t won a game. The club has had to put up with a lot, some that the club & players need to take ownership of, (Oliver & Smith) but so so many click bait nothing stories from the pathetic AFL media towards us & no one else becoming major stories Here’s a few of the stories l can think of 1. Losing a much loved teammate & player in Gus before the 1st round 2. [REDACTED] 3. [REDACTED] 4. [REDACTED] 5. Clayton Oliver 6. Joel Smith saga 7. Club culture 8. Petracca & family carry on 9. Club doctors decision on Petracca 10. Brodie Grundy comparison 11. Mays speech & staging fine 12. Langdons sisters wedding 13. Maynard distractions That’s a lot for an organisation to deal with. Help me out if there’s any others The Steven May staging is the last straw!!!! He’s copped the fine, move on Why is it always the MFC that is the scapegoat?? l really hope all this has galvanised the club behind closed doors, would be nice to show that it has on field

Is that even a thing?? Did you get that PhD on the back of a Cornflakes box?

Oh settle down, what an overreaction

And you my friend are living in Disneyland. May got what he deserved, but has more than enough credits in the bank for me not to worry about. Finally a serious question, why do so many supporters think there’s a conspiracy between the AFL& umpires against the MFC? Im not being a smartarse, just really interested

Rhino Richards instead of face palming everyone who seems to think Petty should be dropped, how about giving your opinion on why he’s still getting a game. There’s nothing I’d rather see than Petty having a positive input, what riles me & a lot of supporters is Goodwins stubbornness playing him forward when it’s a massive failure

Why not Chandler?

Oh cmon you’re comparing Petty to Oliver!!!! Oliver is a least having a crack & has a few more credits over the years Get real!

I wonder what players working hard at Casey think of Petty constantly getting games with zero output. Would imagine it’s a bit demoralising

I have heard the same about Petracca to Collingwood from friend who’s an employee in the AFL. Was told this the end of last season Really hope this is false, but the way we’ve imploded this year in so many ways makes me worried

Agree, but at least Clarry is have a crack, do you honestly think Petty is?

Surely getting rid of Grundy, Jordon & Bedford & bringing in Shcache, Hunter & Billings & oh yeah not trading Petty for two first round draft picks is enough to stamp Goodwins papers We tried the Gawn/Grundy experiment for about two games, played Jordon as the sub more games than not & preferred Hunter!!! & to top it of hardly gave Bedford a chance & re signed Chandler, Spargo & Laurie But we’ve got a great culture??? We will lose to North next week, put your house on it Its been a disaster since the 2021 Covid premiership Over & out

You are delusional if you think Shcache was a better option than Grundy Our list has been ruined by a very stubborn man

Who gives a flying f*#k what Pies supporters think, but we do need to play with a harder edge & get rid of 29yo old plodders who came from other clubs, l can name 3 of them. Oh yeah & then there’s Petty, BBB & Shcache But what burns the most for most is the way we handled Grundy & Jordon, we’ve turned a premiership list into a pack of also ran has beens

By who?? McVee, Windsor, Billings, Langdon, Laurie, Bowey, Rivers, Fritsch, Petty, these guys couldn’t hurt a fly. Salem, Petracca, Gawn, Oliver, TMac, Nibbles,Sparrow, honest hard at the ball players with no mongrel Viney & Kozzie would have a crack but are midgets So that leaves May & a 20yo JVR Not a lot of physicality there I’m afraid Hope you’re feeling ok after your WhatsApp backlash precious

Omnipotent & odiousness, c’mon there still are some supporters on this forum without their heads up their own backsides

Collingwood always have heart & play for jumper & their supporters

We’ll said, we’ve been bashed by the media & other clubs supporters relentlessly for 9 months, the club hasn’t handled it well, but the pile on has been horrendous

Yep he should’ve just run out of the way, how dare he help out the backline Maybe you should re read what you’ve written before posting