Billy

I think Goodwin has a fair bit to answer for 1. Harrison Petty, playing unfit after a serious foot injury, playing forward & gifting him games when he doesn’t deserve them. (This sends a terrible message to the whole list) 2. James Jordon/Lachie Hunter, this one still burns deep. Getting rid of a hard working 23yo popular teammate replacing with a slow 29yo with nothing to offer & a history of poor culture. 3. Brodie Grundy, was treated woefully, promised the world & given nothing. Goodwin gave up on this plan years to early & now we have a champion 33yo ruckman getting bashed every week with no backup. 4. Billings, McAdam, Shcache, BBB (these players shouldn’t even be on our list) none of them have any on field impact. Not all of this is his doing, but the buck stops with him & then of course there’s the elephant in the room that’s been hanging around for 12 months If we beat Freo we would’ve been 3rd so he deserves a bit of slack, but if things spiral out of control for the rest of the season it should be time for a change at the top

Anyone who thinks May should play forward have rocks in their head, could you imagine how many goals Freo would’ve kicked with Petty & Turner as key backs. Tmac unfortunately will have to go forward, l feel for him because he’s been really good down back. Petty & Turnover back to Casey until the deserve to get back in (in defence) McAdam back to Casey also These three are useless at the moment along with Hunter

I don’t rate him at all

We can’t be gifting games to a player that is averaging about 4 possessions a game, weather he plays forward, back or back up ruck. He is uncompetitive, looks uninterested & has shocking body language Play him CHB for Casey & if he shows nothing let him go back to SA if they’ll have him

Sick of all this Maynard rubbish, it derailed our finals last year & mid 2024 we’re still taking about it, get over it!!!!! Maybe a bit of focus about getting our season back on track

He should’ve been at Casey all year

Get rid of him, how Goodwin is gifting him games is outrageous. Play Jefferson or Fullerton, anyone!!! Its beyond embarrassing how he is getting a game

6. Petty 5. Turner 4. McAdam 3. Fritsch 2. Chandler 1. BBB

I know it’s hilarious, spongy grass, humid, wet, cold, windy, heavy dew, light dew, slippery. Excuses excuses, just get out there & play the game!

Spongy grass is going to take it out of them!!! FGS they’re highly paid professional footballers

Anyone So that’s why he’s still in the team?

6. Gawn 5. ANB 4. Tmac 3. Salem 2. Kozzie 1. May

I agree, we can’t keep trying to find positives, give Jeffo a go or Tmac forward or Thommo forward, let’s face it 5 possessions a game would be a bonus

People need to really lighten up a bit & enjoy a40 point win. We’re not head & shoulders above anyone in the competition, we’re in 4th position & will be fighting it out when the whips are cracking with about 12 other teams

Well it definitely hasn’t been from overuse this season

If you’re finding this atrocious l suggest you go home, I’m actually enjoying hopefully a 10 goal win

Still find it hard to swallow that Goodwin preferred Hunter to Jordon

Max thrives on being the big dog, no other ruckman can keep up with him, we tried with Grundy looked what happened. He will get a few little chop outs during the game Looking likely to being a 7xAA ruckman this year

Looking forward to Scotts press conference, wonder who he’ll blame this week, probably the AFL for scheduling his mob for playing in Darwin

Have you got any good news?

5 Petracca 4 ANB 3. Sparrow 2 Gawn 1 Windsor

Good point but we’re on this page to bash the umpires haha

Umpire 22 has pride & place on my dartboard To think it’s umpire appreciation week😂

ANB - Great role model Petty - Kick set shots!!! Kozzie - needs some consistency Windsor - Fantastic first 9 Midfield- Smashed in guts Forwardline - We need one!!!

I think Hunter is a backward step, we’ve got our wingers in Windsor & Langdon & can’t really see Hunter in any other position l’d like to see Laurie play a full game, not just one quarter as the sub in Bowey & Laurie out Billings & Woey either of the outs as sub