Billy

Surely getting rid of Grundy, Jordon & Bedford & bringing in Shcache, Hunter & Billings & oh yeah not trading Petty for two first round draft picks is enough to stamp Goodwins papers We tried the Gawn/Grundy experiment for about two games, played Jordon as the sub more games than not & preferred Hunter!!! & to top it of hardly gave Bedford a chance & re signed Chandler, Spargo & Laurie But we’ve got a great culture??? We will lose to North next week, put your house on it Its been a disaster since the 2021 Covid premiership Over & out

You are delusional if you think Shcache was a better option than Grundy Our list has been ruined by a very stubborn man

Who gives a flying f*#k what Pies supporters think, but we do need to play with a harder edge & get rid of 29yo old plodders who came from other clubs, l can name 3 of them. Oh yeah & then there’s Petty, BBB & Shcache But what burns the most for most is the way we handled Grundy & Jordon, we’ve turned a premiership list into a pack of also ran has beens

By who?? McVee, Windsor, Billings, Langdon, Laurie, Bowey, Rivers, Fritsch, Petty, these guys couldn’t hurt a fly. Salem, Petracca, Gawn, Oliver, TMac, Nibbles,Sparrow, honest hard at the ball players with no mongrel Viney & Kozzie would have a crack but are midgets So that leaves May & a 20yo JVR Not a lot of physicality there I’m afraid Hope you’re feeling ok after your WhatsApp backlash precious

Omnipotent & odiousness, c’mon there still are some supporters on this forum without their heads up their own backsides

Collingwood always have heart & play for jumper & their supporters

We’ll said, we’ve been bashed by the media & other clubs supporters relentlessly for 9 months, the club hasn’t handled it well, but the pile on has been horrendous

Yep he should’ve just run out of the way, how dare he help out the backline Maybe you should re read what you’ve written before posting

The lack of football knowledge on this site is embarrassing. Football is a really tough game, accidents & collisions do happen & in this case causing a really nasty injury. Sure Moore went hard at the contest, but it’s within the rules, l just wish our boys played with the same physicality And to all the budding doctors out there, leave it the experts. Get we’ll Trac that was beyond brave

Good Onya Layzie, l for one would’ve preferred the 4 points, this Maynard rubbish has been going on for 9 months. Big tough supporters who don’t even go to the game because their feelings were hurt during the 23 finals campaign, complaining, there’s the soft underbelly

Sorry, but this just makes my blood boil

That is the dumbest comment ever to come out of Demonland & that’s saying something. Yes he’s had issues of late, but he’s a four time B&F winner. Remember not long ago there was talk about him becoming one of the best ever Demons Wake up & grow up, ya big baby

As soon as l saw Petty selected l knew we would lose. The most uncompetitive player in the AFL Goodwins stubbornness has cost us any chance of finals this year

MOVE ON FOR GODS SAKE, it ruined our finals last year, let’s not let it happen again this year. Its an 8 point game & if we get distracted again we can kiss finals goodbye l love Gus & hated what happened, but we need to show that we are a united team & play the team not the man

I understand all this, but he is uncompetitive at the moment, doing absolutely nothing for his or the team’s confidence Goodwin needs to start being a coach & make some hard decisions instead of dropping the same old fall guys Team moral is taking a hit

He’s a key forward?? Ah thanks 👍

Why unfortunately??

Can anyone please explain how Petty is playing, please!!! Collingwood with half a team in will play with heart, something we’ve been severely been lacking & Petty especially Hope Laurie gets a full game, we know what we’ll get with Billings so make him sub, give Bill a go & see what he’s got

So are we gifting Petty another game?

That’s the way precious 👍

Not point, arguing, Cranky we really have some of the softest supporters in the AFL. The Collingwood supporters are banding together now, they’re got half there team out, but they’ll be there in force, where as some of ours are broken & just can’t do it anymore Toughen up people, it’s a game that you’re supposed to enjoy!!!!!

I’m sick to death of all this Maynard stuff & the excuses of certain supporters, harden up & get to the game if you can, the season is on the line, we need all the support we can get. Imagine how good it will be when we win!!!

The mind boggles with some his decisions

I think Goodwin has a fair bit to answer for 1. Harrison Petty, playing unfit after a serious foot injury, playing forward & gifting him games when he doesn’t deserve them. (This sends a terrible message to the whole list) 2. James Jordon/Lachie Hunter, this one still burns deep. Getting rid of a hard working 23yo popular teammate replacing with a slow 29yo with nothing to offer & a history of poor culture. 3. Brodie Grundy, was treated woefully, promised the world & given nothing. Goodwin gave up on this plan years to early & now we have a champion 33yo ruckman getting bashed every week with no backup. 4. Billings, McAdam, Shcache, BBB (these players shouldn’t even be on our list) none of them have any on field impact. Not all of this is his doing, but the buck stops with him & then of course there’s the elephant in the room that’s been hanging around for 12 months If we beat Freo we would’ve been 3rd so he deserves a bit of slack, but if things spiral out of control for the rest of the season it should be time for a change at the top

I think Goodwin has a fair bit to answer for 1. Harrison Petty, playing unfit after a serious foot injury, playing forward & gifting him games when he doesn’t deserve them. (This sends a terrible message to the whole list) 2. James Jordon/Lachie Hunter, this one still burns deep. Getting rid of a hard working 23yo popular teammate replacing with a slow 29yo with nothing to offer & a history of poor culture. 3. Brodie Grundy, was treated woefully, promised the world & given nothing. Goodwin gave up on this plan years to early & now we have a champion 33yo ruckman getting bashed every week with no backup. 4. Billings, McAdam, Shcache, BBB (these players shouldn’t even be on our list) none of them have any on field impact. Not all of this is his doing, but the buck stops with him & then of course there’s the elephant in the room that’s been hanging around for 12 months If we beat Freo we would’ve been 3rd so he deserves a bit of slack, but if things spiral out of control for the rest of the season it should be time for a change at the top