Rodney (Balls) Grinter

Accurate

Jonathan Brown has gone pretty hard on this issue. Got a somewhat better perspective on the issue than Slobo.

All 16mins?

Yep, storm AFL house time. ...since you are one of those MEGA guys.

So as an asides, did anyone ever free Jack Trengrove?

I just want Steven May to punch a tribunal member in the head.

FFS what absolute BS The AFL just hate admitting they are wrong and will only cave when they are forced to by leagal action. But seriously where the consistency and resonablness in this. How is JVR more guilty than Crips. Where did giving the player any benifit of doubt regarding duty of care Vs made a small misjudgment and accidentally made minor contact (not actually injured vs he felt a shock at the time F witts). It really irks me that the people that make these determinations look at the event in super slow motion freeze frame and make out like there is a rational descision making process that goes through the players head when all this happens. Did these people ever actually play the game? The AFL needs to go back over the footage of every game this season and suspend the dozens of players that similarly neglected their duty of care and made contact similar to JVR's. I'm normally pretty understanding and progressive when it comes to these issues, but all this duty of care and protection of players health and safety has got to the point where it's lost the plot. There does need to be a point that the players accept that by taking the feild, they are putting themselves at risk of accidental contact that is an unavoidable part of the game. Where is it going to stop? Suspend two players for an accidental head clash when they both only have eyes for the ball. You know things are seriously out of whack when Jonathan Brown presents a clearer and more credible argument than the official rulings from the league.

I think that would actually be more effective in making the point

I see not so much the crowds, but the grass roots amature and jnr leagues in the area as the reason it's so important to have the Suns there. Local and women's Aussie Rules footy in SEQ is on the rise. https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theage.com.au/sport/afl/battleground-brisbane-the-afl-insurgency-and-league-s-brutal-response-20230323-p5cuoi.html "Early into this season, the code boasts 38,000 registered participants (58,000 at its 2022 peak) at the grassroots level from northern NSW through Queensland, according to figures provided by the AFL. It has added 34 teams – half of them for girls – to its Youth Community Football program and lists 170 community Aussie rules clubs in 11 leagues. Swann said a common complaint from the suburbs was the lack of grounds to accommodate record numbers of juniors. The NRL was less forthcoming with its data, but said it had 54,550 Queensland participants, up more than 20 per cent. It would not say when the figure was captured."

So maybe it's not realistic, but it would be nice if we did! 😉 I actually think our 2021 season was pretty close. Bar a few games like the unfortunate loss to Collingwood and perhaps one or two others, I thought we we convincingly in control of most games. Even though we only won alot of them with a winning margin of 20 - 30 points, we're generally so in control of those games that we always looked like we'd win and were close to unbeatable.

Yeah, Jeff and his cheap and nasty Brown and Gold (wees and poos) sports jacket - case in point!

Ooooooo tin cape, I haven't seen one of those before!

Honestly, I have a soft spot for the Sun's and hope they do well, because I think the Gold Coast and South East Queensland in particular is much more receptive and fertile ground for Australian Rules than Sydney will probably ever be, but trying to encourage support through rubbish biased commentary is just pathetic. Imagine had it have been Hawthorn in their prime that piped GC in yesterday's game. It would have been never ending praise for this great Hawthorn team that 'just do what good teams do and find a way to win, even when they're not playing their best football'. Maybe Dunstal is just sour, because he was a part of the Clarkson / Mitchel replacement strategy and recient Hawthorn recruiting strategy and he can see his beloved Hawks are in for a decade or more of pain and uncompetitiveness and it's at least partly his fault?

Not wanting to be all doom and gloom, because I'm glad we got the 4 points, I'll take that any day of the week and generally I think we are playing ok and in a decient position win/loss wise. BUT I think there are some aspects of our defensive game that are rubbish at the moment. My recollection of the last two goals that the GC kicked, were the result of some sloppy defending on our behalf close to the goal line that wouldn't have previously got through our once elite backline. We can talk about bias against us with respects to umpiring decisions and JVR's suspension all we like, but I really hope the coaches and players throughly review that final 5mins of play carefully and we learn some lessons from that. Goody publicly stated how well we played in the last quarter and generally I'd agree, but in our near capitulation, I think we actually lost our heads a bit and if it wasn't for their rubbish shot on goal in the last minute, we would have had an unfortunate loss. Against any decient top 8 side and we loose that game.

That free for holding the ball they gave to Ellis I think it was made me puke. He had hold of him for all of a millisecond and the ball was handpassed clear. If it was Dusty who was tackled, no free holding the ball and the naritive would have been about how strong Dusty is and they they just can't contain him in a tackle, because of his brute strenght to break out of it. In actual fact, the Ellis tackle on this occasion really wasn't even all that good and our player (I forget who) basically just slipped it and got a handball clear. The free kick should never have been played anywhere on the ground, let alone right in front of goal in a close game. I was quite ok receiving the Gawn free as an evener upper for that one. Fact was in the final quarter we out played them for the most part, kicked poorly, which kept them in the game when they shouldn't have been, they then got a bunch of goals through part fluke and part bad defending on our behalf and had a chance to steal the game when the shouldn't have been in it.

Except Razor Ray. He's every Ch 7 comentators favorite celebrity umpire. I've even seen kids running around in bright yellow T-shirts with Razor's number on the back. Love you Ray - now F off.

Yeah I thought exactly the same thing. How he can do that and still be considered negligent of his duty of care to the other player is beyond me.

Roo got shafted Christian hates Demons Appeal this injustice

That incident should have got 5 weeks. Clumsy accident my backside. Hawkins was flailing about all over the place hoping something would connect. This notion that players do stuff like that by accident is garbage, it was far less of a football action than either of Kossies or JVR's incidents, because he had the ball and wasn't contesting it. He was aggressively fending off May.

Mind blown 🤯

Since when do Melbourne ever appeal this stuff?

I think it's all in context really. A shocker game from Clarry is anything that he's not up amoung the top coaches votes. I'd say Brownlow, but the umpires clearly don't have a clue about rating players games, so that's not a valid metric. In other words, a shocker game for Clarry is the best game of the year for 95% of standard AFL players.

I'm seeing the next 3 or 4 games as a really important block to get out team humming to take on Collingwood on Kings Birthday, which I expect to be a near finals like test of atmosphere, intensity and consequence. Who knows what we will get from Hawthorn (a big part of me hopes they are puss that we can slaughter with ease and total dominance), but Port and Freo should be competitive enough to get our heads in the right place for playing genuinely contending teams.

Not sure if others have commented much on this already, but I was really pleased with Bowey's game last night. His form has been a bit up and down this season and over the past 12 months we've found that he is actually human, but I get the impression that he's returning to his best 2021 premiership finals era type tenacious, unflappable, unbeatable and undropable form.

Totally agree Sue. This issue grates on my immensely. I mean seriously. What you get is a series of disconnected statements about the game from the coaches and spend half your time trying to figure out what their answer relates to. You've got to feel for the coaches too as they've got to be aware of this, that one of their main chances to explain the story to the fans is massively compromised. The AFL are so very dum in alot of respects. This one also falls into the same basket of not having enough dedicated cameras and technology to do propper post goal review. They'll spend nearly a billion dollars on a new stadium that Tasmania 'must have' to make it suitable for AFL standard, but then won't fork out a few thousand dollars to have dedicated cameras setup in the best locations for goal line review, so we'll get a game that gets controversially decided on some blurry vision with the goal umpires butt three quarters blocking the view of the ball as it crosses.