GCDee

this one looks the fairest of the lot tbh...

no chance... 6 & 30 something.

IF this is true what an absolute [censored]. We have been so accommodating to him, he will be at best a 35 goal per year forward at freo... Actually scrap that with Neale gone and Fyfe will get his annual injury he will be lucky to hit 30.

mmmm Shiel is just a bit over rated IMO.... I think May fills more of a need for us.

GC need to bank points for next year... 5 & 2019 second for May & 24

Well I guess we will have to agree to disagree here. I would prefer to hold Hogan to his contract next year & target May as a FA next year assuming he doesn't go to the dogs or pies this year. Jesse hasn't come out and said he wants to go home... he is open to it but its clear he is also happy to stay, I would hardly say that us holding him against his will.

Or here's an idea.... Get the actual value of our contracted star forward & then pay a fair price for May.... Why should we sacrifice to get the deal done? Why isn't Freo sacrificing to ship Neale off to get Hogan & Lobb in? Why isn't Brissy sacrificing and just paying overs to get Neale? Why isn't Collingwood sacrificing & paying overs to bring Beams home?

Agree with this all the pressure is on the little man. 5, 23 & 30 has to be a minimum!!! 5 & 11 is still what I would be pushing for as this really is his value. I really get the sense that Mahoney will blink first however & fold with just pick 5 or 5 & 23 and we end up losing Hogan for May & change.

They also got a future 4th back... ? that could potentially be just a 5-10 pick downgrade for a pick 7, 2 years ago....

Cmon man... 8 year contract we could demand 5 first rounders or no deal. Lol

Can we just sign him on a 8 year contract so we can put this [censored] to bed once and for all?

You know it... And watch all this years big trades go down on Wednesday nights trade TV special.

Haha Bell is totally Lewis Litt from season 1. Such a chump who no body in the office likes.

So why chase a guy for 4+ years, bring him to your facilities whilst he is contracted and offer him a multi million dollar deal? Freo are actually pathetic and if they are honestly leaking this stuff they are dragging Jesse's name through the mud, & for what to get him cheaply? Unless something had changed between this time last week whilst he was over seas and Jesse has become a leader of the Hells Angels this is just absolute dribble. Bell is a complete waste of space in this setting and is clearly so far out of his league, I want nothing more than for this to blow up in his face.

I think 5 & 11 is a very fair deal for both parties... or 5 and a swap of future firsts... Just feels like we aren't getting value here and looks like we are going to over pay for May.

Am I going crazy but in what world is Lachie Neale worth more than Jesse Hogan? Like seriously.... 1 is a decent mid who is an accumulator who has happened to win 2 B & F's at a rabble club whilst never coming top 10 in the Brownlow. the other is a 23 year old key forward who has the best numbers at this age as any key forward in the league. Once in a generation player. The thought that Freo will get Hogan & Change for Neale makes me want to spew. I simply do not get it....

Really hoping this is the deal... Imagine if the dockers slide to bottom 3 next year.. wouldn't that be glorious. Hell I'd even throw in 33 to the mix

Report earlier in the week suggested us & Essendon were after Ben Long.

5, 23 & Freo 2019 first. for Hogan & 2019 first. Seems pretty fair to me.

Just imagine the size of the contract GC could offer him with May, Lynch & KK (who was on a very decent contract) off their books? No doubt the AFL will kick in the 500k ambassador allowance to go with it. 1.5 mil plus.

Pretty rough deal for us here... Maybe GC can trade pick 3 to the crows for two later first rounds. Package may, late first (say 13) & KK for Hogan & maybe a later pick

So who the hell are we getting in to fill all our empty list spots??? Let's give Tommy bugg a call back?

I would be absolutely livid if I was Hogan. Who the [censored] chases you over and over for 4 straight years, he finally sticks his neck out and takes a leap to join their club and they wont even pay 5 & 23? GAGF freo... you enjoy being [censored] forever

This would be so funny. Wasnt it tom Scully leaving that got us Hogan?

What a deal for the dockers... I think we need a second coming from freo to us.