dazzledavey36

Linc McCarthy, Darcy Gardiner, Keidan Coleman, Tom Doedee. They missed both premiership players in Will Ashcroft and Jack Payne for half a year due to injury and then lost their number 1 ruckman in Oscar McInerney for the grand final.

What happened to 'Simon's Sign Off' segment? Have they canned that already??

Just wanted to highlight that literally everything you predicted, happened! I too was also in the camp of playing Campbell against the Roos. Everyone would have seen that only a few weeks back Campbell was able to physically beat Xerri in a practice game. If he is there to be used, use him.. even up forward he adds a solid body next to JVR and at least competes in the air against Comben. If Max is going through personal issues then don't play him. This is literally the reason why we brought Campbell in to step in when needed but also give Gawn a chop out so that he's not being physically burnt out.

Ironically we were one of the most attacking and high scoring teams in the AFL back in 2017-2018. We leaked too many goals playing a Sam Frost and Oscar McDonald led defence which resulted in him being super defensive after that.

You're kidding right.

I felt like losing Andy Moniz Wakefield was actually actually a big loss for us this year. He was going to another ground ball player down back that could not only provide some toughness but also lock down on the best medium to small forward and beat them well.

We're not a team known to make big changes even after a big loss like that. Clearly Jefferson is gone with a fractured hand so you'd think Johnson comes back in. I did see Fullarton take some pretty solid clunks up forward today in the VFL, could he possibly be an option for Jefferson? I feel like eventually we either need a Fullarton or Campbell playing together with Gawn at some stage. Today he looked completely gassed and Campbell completely dominated the ruck at VFL level. Even as a big body up forward perhaps. Wanted Sharp gone last week and got questioned by a few folks on here.. where are they now? He's a genuine VFL depth plodder who i much prefer Bailey Laurie playing instead of him. Hopefully Steven May is a chance. We are shot once he actually retires. Our depth is pretty limited to be honest....

Oh don't worry, it's already started on X..

I'm a very big admirer of Adam Kingsley.

Oh for gods sake.. this is not only poor by Goodwin but absolutely disrespectful to Xerri who absolutely pansted Gawn. Just own it and move on. If its personal then don't mention anything and just say he had a bad day at the office. Watch every journo all flock in at once to grab a headline.

He just doesn't want to be here. Body language tells it all and our performances like today will only fuel that further.

Malcolm Blight let a few slip by at Geeling before he got the ultimate at Adelaide. But i agree, do whatever it takes to get him.

Goodwin and Tim Lamb have completely butchered our list management. Fancy offering a cooked Viney a contract extension all because Norf bluffed us. Completely disheartened with this footy club.

Sack Goodwin. I tolerated last year but today has done it for me.. officially off him now. Since 2021 we've gotten worse as each year goes by. The lovey dovey fake persona this off season was just a cover up for the rot that still exist within the footy club.

Bye bye Goodwin. You've found ways to make us worse each year after 2021.

Chandler is our best midfielder so far.

Gawn is cooooked...

What the actual [censored] was Jake Lever doing??

Sharp is so [censored]

We genuinely make it so hard on ourselves. Gawn is cooked btw

Petracca, Viney, Gawn and Oliver are dead set liabilities right now. Throw Rivers in there, Sparrow, Salem anyone! Try something Goodwin FFS!

Gawn getting absolutely slaughtered. Should have played Campbell as he would have had Xerrinfor strength.

Once again Petracca, Viney and Oliver being shown up for why we are so heavily reliant in them and why clubs have easily worked them out since 2021. Goodwin is clueless and has no plan B.

Jeeesus the skill level from our MFC players in Brown and Campbell have been atrocious so far in this last quarter.

Yeah I've been a pretty staunch supporter but he's heading towards delist material. 3rd year in the system and hasn't shown any improvement at all. As you say, for such a big guy he does lack that physical presence.