dazzledavey36

From Fox.. Could Melbourne — yes, the Demons — look at him on night one? It’d be a big call, but that’s the big whisper doing the rounds among draft sources, who also believe Hawthorn and the Western Bulldogs have some interest in Pickett

I have watched a few videos of Cumming and and I'm yet to see any special traits that commands being taken as a top 10 pick. He just reminds me too much of Tom Sparrow and hes a plodder at AFL level.

Or Harry Armstrong last year and yet looked how that got out. Its all guess work with zero substance and no research or insight into our list make up. It would be a massive blunder if we picket Schubert. Its like watching Lucas Cook/Josh Schache all over again.

So now the board is responsible for the on field playing performance on gameday?? Probably one of the wildest takes I've read on here 🤣

To add further to this i have lost count how many times we have found ourselves in moments of the game over the past two years where Max has lined up for goal to either put us in front of give us momentum and yet misses his shot at crucial stages of the game. He does a lot right from a playing perspective and is a champion of a ruckman, but his on field leadership leaves a lot to be desired.

Are the board responsible for Joel Smith indiscretions? Clayton Oliver off field antics? Steven May belting teammates? Which one is it?

Considering @Dee Boys knows a player within the club on a person level really well, then I'd be hesitant to question his insight on this. I have previously spoken to a now ex player of the club on this and whilst he rates Max as a decent guy, he simply doesn't rate him as a leader. Said Nathan Jones was the best captain he's played under during his time at the club.

Pretty sure there has been a change of social media person. New person started not long ago.

Dont rate Max as a captain and never have. Champion player but.

Zero comparisons to Bowey

Robey wont last to our pick

Dovaston and Sharp would be a dream.

Looks meh to me to be honest. His kicks are just high long bombs to a pack and he is nothing like Hayden Young who has that speed and evasiveness to slice through. Actually see a bit of Rivers in him and he's prone to just bomb the footy at times as the safe option. Wouldn't be my option for those early picks

Yeah dont know.. I didnt see anything in 2021 that suggested he was going to be a future gun.

Plays too much like Tom Sparrow for my liking..

Melbourne was the first AFL team to reach out to Robey following his third Talent League match. As Robey says, it’s “pretty much skyrocketed from there”. “By the end of the combine, I’ll be up to all 18,” he says.