dazzledavey36

For the benefit of his career then yes, it's the right decision.

He's not selected.

Based on your observations do we think it's only going to be the one change only with McDonald for Melksham?

How's he moving?

Goodwin has always been about whole team mentality attitude. Think back to when we took the whole squad to Perth back in 2021.

Hibberd?

Times like this I hate living interstate. Enjoy everyone! Training updates would be greatly appreciated.

I'm reluctant to believe someone that was shouting all year that the Petty forward experiment would be a complete failure and would never work..

Lol taking word of a GC nuffie supporter off bigfooty. It's no different to some of thr comments written here about MJ. I find your comments strange about him "struggling to get his hands on the footy" last year at VFL level when clearly according to his VFL stats he had a number of games where he had over 20 plus disposals and mostly averaging mid to high teens. He also had a number of games where he took some high number of marks one which included 13 marks against Geelong. So remind me, which part does it look like he's struggling to get his hands on the footy?

Full game. He's been sub twice since then

Mac Andrew was playing senior AFL footy last year mate and had a fairly strong VFL year.

I wouldn't be stressing about anything. Tom Morris on SEN this morning was saying that Melbourne were keeping their cards extremely close to their chest regarding all matters. Journo's are just spit balling because they're struggling to gain any information from within the club. He'll play.

Kynan Brown put in a mammoth performance yesterday in their wildcard round against Northern Knights. 25 disposals, 5 tackles, 4 marks and kicked 5.2 for the day. We have a beauty on our hands I reckon.

I think this is why I was equally shocked with this selection. We know Goody has a love for bringing in recruits who are genuine competitors. Watching his draft highlights and then most games at Casey this year he is far from the competitive animal that the likes of JVR possess when we were watching him last year. I feel like I've learnt my lesson from writing off McVee last year after watching some underwhelming performances so fingers cross he has a big summer.

And Hibbo's declining the same way as "might Nev Jetta" was in his last year. You're simply not replacing him from anyone from our back 6 unless there's an injury to our smalls.

I'm sorry @Demonstrative did my comment somehow upset ypu to warrant a facepalm?

He was down at Box Hill yesterday watching Casey and wasn't wearing a moonboot and at all and looked fine.

Port

He's got 1 game before he potentially gets a week off then 2 after that. He'll be fine.

You do realise the last time Hibberd played on Elliott was last year round 21 and Elliot taught him a lesson and kicked 4 on Hibbo right... So many are so fixated on Hibberd playing when he's clearly just about done as a footballer. Goody not playing him in a full game since Geelong where Gary Rohan also taught him a lesson is why he hasn't been able to break in. Some serious lack of respect for McVee who's done the big jobs on the likes of Dusty and Charlie Cameron. He'll play on Elliot and do the job just fine.

Blake Howes also missed significant parts of the season due to injury and was never near full fitness. Jefferson has played all year.