chook fowler

AGREE 3+

Think you are under-estimating Bomber. Maybe Geelong are still enjoying the foundations put in place during his reign. Also Essendon seem much more lively than under Hird which plces him in a vulnerable position when he returns. It seems to me Bomber has a personality that builds good relationships with players - Hird seems more aloof.

My favourite is Nathan Bassett

It might be the Grand Final!

As a Medico I know the diagnostic process is very inexact and that it takes time for many conditions to declare themselves. If a stress fracture was forming the outcome may well have been the same. A delay in diagnosis may make very little difference. Sometimes you just have to see what develops and only act when the picture is clear.

You've got to be joking. Great viewing, good exposure and keeps Roos involved with the media. We are not in a position to dictate to Roos - if we did he'd be off like a rocket and rightfully so.

I remember hearing that players under Alan Jeans were always scared to tell them they were injured because they thought he felt it was the sign of a character flaw. I think you are from the same school Old Dee.

Classy response by Trengove to his injury on the website. I'm sure he will reinvent himself. Has great character that kid.

Think Healy is only now interested in us because of the strong Swans connections.

All the best Jack - hope it explains the mobility problems and it responds well to treatment

See Sylvia is in the [censored] with Lyon after getting reported in the WAFL - also not exactly dominating there. Continues to waste his talent and no ability to reflect on past mistakes. Pleased to see the back of him

Hope he can,because hes a real trier - reminds me a bit of Godfrey

Would have Grundy in a heart beat.Would take him ahead of Natanui

The VFL reports seem more informative this year. Good luck getting Nicho to tidy up his disposal. Looks like Salem and The Toump making progress

Hamstring i believe. No more detail than that

Trengoves lack of pace may make the tagging role difficult. He must have a biomechanical problem to be sorted before anything else

Comparisons are odious - Jones is Jones and gives us plenty. Who knows what he would have been like if he didnt have to do it all in the midfield unassisted as hes done in the last few years. Made mincemeat of Murphy in a one on one and he"s no slouch. Jones may well be in all australian contention this year and not before time.

Think Gawn will be more likely to take a contested mark than Spencer so could be more useful up forward when resting

How does anyone know anything - i get the impression from watching him he has some natural aggression and is an extrovert around the club. Warnock seems quiet and timid. All Im saying is he needs more time especially with Stafford who I believe doing well as our ruck coach.

A Roos type player to a tee - knows his role and limitations and will sacrifice for the team. Disposal not as bad as many others.

You're joking. Would rather spend the time having my haemorrhoids banded

That show I have decided is unwatchable - 2giant egos vying for attention. Tossers!

fair enough, there are limits

Supporters are never consistent, rational or measured. it's part of the attraction, otherwise it would be very boring

Max is still very young and will become a beast in time. I think the fact that he looks older than he is raises expectations