Melbourne
Pick 1. Dustin Martin
What could’ve been Melbourne fans…Fyfe AND Dusty!?
It was damn tough separating the star duo, but we went with the once-in-a-generation type talent. The face of this Tigers dynasty, Martin is close to winning every accolade a midfielder could dream of.
The two-time Norm Smith, two-time premier and two-time Gary Ayres medallist knows when to show up. September.
That’s not to say he hasn’t performed as consistently in the home and away season, as Martin broke the record for most Brownlow votes in a season with 36 in 2017.
Martin hasn’t played less than 20 games or dropped below an average of 20 disposals a game in each of his 10 seasons with Richmond, stacking up to 5,707 touches and 251 goals from his 225 game career. Dusty is our pick of the 2009 AFL draft.
Melbourne
Pick 2. Nat Fyfe
Look away now Dees fans. The steal of the draft at pick 20, Fyfe has fashioned a career like no other.
Fyfe’s debut season was off to a flyer, having polled five Brownlow votes from his 18 matches in 2010.
The Freo skipper soon went onto with the AFLCA’s Young Player of the Year award and a spot in the All-Australian squad in the following season after averaging 25 touches and four tackles per match.
From then on he has won two Brownlow medals, three All-Australian selections and three Best and Fairests at Fremantle.
Fyfe has polled a staggering 174 votes from 162 eligible games and sits eighth overall for three-vote performances.
He boasts career averages of 25.7 disposals, 4.5 marks, 4.0 tackles, 5.7 clearances and 14.4 contested possessions a game. Simply amazing.
Richmond
Pick 3. Max Gawn
One of the biggest risers in our list, Gawn comes into third overall after originally being selected by the Demons at 34th in the draft.
The 208cm tall bearded ruckman was another to slowly bloom into their stride, Gawn spent seven years in the system before collecting any major accolade.
Come 2016, he was given All-Australian honours and would eventually find himself within the side on two more occasions.
Gawn also went on to win back-to-back best and fairests for Melbourne between 2018 and 2019, with the former year also seeing him crowned as the AFLCA’s Player of the Year.
Gawn currently holds the record for most hitouts in a season with 1,119 in 2018 and holds the top three hitout seasons in Demons history.
Fremantle
Pick 4. Jack Gunston
North Melbourne
Pick 5. Daniel Talia
Sydney
Pick 6. Ben Cunnington
West Coast
Pick 7. Mitch Duncan
Port Adelaide
Pick 8. Ben Stratton
Port Adelaide
Pick 9. Davis Astbury
Essendon
Pick 10. Lewis Jetta
Melbourne
Pick 11. Brad Sheppard
Originally taken one selection after Rohan at 7th overall in 2009, Sheppard holds the bragging rights in our list after a prolonged career with the Eagles so far.
A season-ending hamstring injury meant Sheppard missed his side’s Grand Final victory in 2018, but he looked to bounce back the next year with a selection in the All-Australian 40-man squad.
Carlton
Pick 12. Tom Scully
The first name called out on draft night, Scully looked prepared to lead his draft class after his debut season.
Having polled the most votes in the rising star award between the 2009 selections and falling second overall to Dan Hannebery, Scully looked a great chance to be the new face of the Demons.
Scully’s highly-anticipated move to the then-newcomers in Greater Western Sydney sparked an uproar from Melbourne fans after he departed at the end of his two-year contract.
He has since shown why he was so rated highly for his run and carry game and silky delivery of the ball for both the Giants and Hawthorn.
Adelaide
Pick 13. Jake Carlisle
Sydney
Pick 14. Sam Reid
Western Bulldogs
Pick 15. Gary Rohan
Port Adelaide
Pick 16. Allen Christensen
Geelong
Pick 17. Jamie Macmillan