Was sent an email today from the club about the 'Advisory Panel' - in it they said that the club had a new logo for next year:

I for one am not overwhelmed by it. I prefer the current logo. Thoughts?

current one is better

Was sent an email today from the club about the 'Advisory Panel' - in it they said that the club had a new logo for next year:

I for one am not overwhelmed by it. I prefer the current logo. Thoughts?

its a joke isnt it.. must have been done by a consultant group of 10 kindergarten kids !!

would have hoped for something a little more.. well.. anything !! lol

Underwhelming doesnt quite do justice !!

it's very... "melbourne" isn't it?

and just incase you weren't following, i meant BORING.

it's very.. "melbourne" isn't it?

and just incase you weren't following, i meant BORING.

got it in a flash !! lol

Was sent an email today from the club about the 'Advisory Panel' - in it they said that the club had a new logo for next year:

I for one am not overwhelmed by it. I prefer the current logo. Thoughts?

Yuck.

I'm actually hoping it fades when I put it on my car.

the M just makes it look retarded...

fark we suck at this game...

the M spoils it, a normal M would make it look a lot better

got it in a flash !! lol

I actually hoped they were joking when I saw that earlier today

Please everyone who fills out the "Advisory Panel" do not encourage this crap

its a joke isnt it.. must have been done by a consultant group of 10 kindergarten kids !!

would have hoped for something a little more.. well.. anything !! lol

Underwhelming doesnt quite do justice !!

Yes.

Overall not a good day in the history of the MFC

the M just makes it look retarded...

fark we suck at this game...

could not agree more. lets keep the normal logo or change it to the 80's one, or even the MFC one like Carlton. The new one is s*** and boring. Anyway, if we are changing anything, it should be the alternative strip and that should be the 80's heritage jumper IMO

hello any mention of 150 years?

It's [censored] weak. One of the strongest points of the MFC marketing is our current logo which has been used very well over the past 12-15 years since first unveiled. To change it now would be ridiculous. Especially for that real beige number !!

Is this a joke? This is not confirmed is it?

Your telling me this logo that looks like a 10 year old with any computer skills could do is our new logo?

And so this is taking over the demon with the m over the top and melbourne fc to the side?

Apparently it is under review. But if the advisory panel i.e. us, give it a massive thumbs down we should be able to avoid it. I Hope

so they are trying to put that new logo to replace the logo in my sig?

This better be some sort of prank because that is a horrible design. Our current logo is fine.

i understand what angle they're going for... 150th year, looking for a more traditional feel to the logo, as you'd see with the carlton logo, or something like that... it just doesn't work all that well i'm afraid...

Hate it. Has no character

I actually hoped they were joking when I saw that earlier today

Please everyone who fills out the "Advisory Panel" do not encourage this crap

Agree totally!! If Advisory Panel is intended to have any meaningfull input surely things such as the logo and importance of MFC logos remaining red & blue would be included on feedback sought. Perhaps Judd has seen the 2007 logos gone to B & W and is why going for Pies!!

if this goes ahead i will rate this higher in dissapointment than not getting judd! that looks so plain and dull its not funny at all!

It's plain and mediocre, but moreover very sad.

Was sent an email today from the club about the 'Advisory Panel' - in it they said that the club had a new logo for next year:

I for one am not overwhelmed by it. I prefer the current logo. Thoughts?

I like it, straight to the point

It's plain and mediocre, but moreover very sad.

I agree!

Yeah, I think its probably a good time for a new logo(150th yr and all), and they've obviously tried to do something more minimalistic and traditional like the Carlton or Geelong ones, which is fine, but that... that just screams "NOTHING".