On 5/26/2017 at 0:17 AM, A F said:

Urgh. MFCSS at its finest. How could the Tyson, Salem and Hunt deal possibly only be seen as a shocker or break even?

Tyson is a cusp A grader (certainly B+ at the moment), despite some of the crap I read on here; Salem will be A grade if his form and development continues; and Hunt could be absolutely anything. He's a B+ grader currently.

Versus Kelly. Who this year is playing A grade football. 

In fact, I'd argue that the deal will either be seen as break even or we're well, well, well ahead.

Tyson on the cusp of being an A grader? That would mean 70% of our list (and most other lists) contain A Graders.

15 minutes ago, Northern Summer said:

Tyson on the cusp of being an A grader? That would mean 70% of our list (and most other lists) contain A Graders.

Yeah, good on ya.

47 minutes ago, Northern Summer said:

Tyson on the cusp of being an A grader? That would mean 70% of our list (and most other lists) contain A Graders.

Tyson is C+ if we want to look at where we really are

he has guts but he is nowhere near A Grade

1 minute ago, Sir Why You Little said:

Tyson is C+ if we want to look at where we really are

he has guts but he is nowhere near A Grade

Spot on! Not sure how someone can be 'on the cusp of being an A grader' when they get all their possessions on the outside and make more clangers than most other players each week. In all fairness he will be one of those good generally best 22 players that will play 200+ games, but never be in that top dozen.

18 minutes ago, Northern Summer said:

Spot on! Not sure how someone can be 'on the cusp of being an A grader' when they get all their possessions on the outside and make more clangers than most other players each week. In all fairness he will be one of those good generally best 22 players that will play 200+ games, but never be in that top dozen.

Yep...

4 hours ago, Northern Summer said:

Spot on! Not sure how someone can be 'on the cusp of being an A grader' when they get all their possessions on the outside and make more clangers than most other players each week. In all fairness he will be one of those good generally best 22 players that will play 200+ games, but never be in that top dozen.

Just out of interest, why does one getting all their possessions on the outside stop them being an A-grader?

We don't need every single midfielder to be a contested ball freak and none of them to be any good in uncontested link-up play.

I also dispute the proposition that Tyson "gets all his possessions on the outside" but that's a different story.

FWIW, Tyson's just an average player IMO. B-grade at his best. 

On 20/05/2017 at 9:32 PM, dazzledavey36 said:

No..

Yeah real bad idea that

One trick pony. Immediately turned it over after his first mark and almost did it again with the next.

No