Putting another fork into this thread - for all the kids watching at home - I just troll-lol'd BH.

Did you lol?

I know I did.

Phew. I read that one without fainting....

Maybe we just forget what you said re 2011 example.

As dc said ...ok

But what a doozy that was...

Ok fork in, I'm done..

Cameron will be a star..

Who cares if he will be a star as it doesn't effect us.

And the 2011 premiership was won more by A grade players then a few select Stars, in future if you choose to dismiss someones opinion then at least provide some argument as to why rather then beat around the bush with simpleton comments

Who cares if he will be a star as it doesn't effect us.

And the 2011 premiership was won more by A grade players then a few select Stars, in future if you choose to dismiss someones opinion then at least provide some argument as to why rather then beat around the bush with simpleton comments

Are you all there? You know, up stairs?

Firstly you make the clearly wrong, and arguably idiotic statement that Geelong 2011 had no stars.

Then you argue amongst yourself to somehow try and deflect any real argument coming your way.

You then want everyone to forget you even said it, either because a: you realise how stupid it was, or b: you genuinely didn't want to derail the thread.

Finally you finish off with a smart arz comment asking H_T to provide an argument - after numerous times saying you didn't want to rehash that argument.

You sir, are my new favourite.

Edited June 28, 201213 yr by Deestroy All

Who cares if he will be a star as it doesn't effect us.

And the 2011 premiership was won more by A grade players then a few select Stars, in future if you choose to dismiss someones opinion then at least provide some argument as to why rather then beat around the bush with simpleton comments

bugger it, I'm stupid enough to buy in. lets have a crack at this.

Josh Hunt B- grade player, lucky enough enough to play in 3 premierships.

Matthew Scarlett 6 time All Australian. One of the greatest full backs the game has seen.

Tom Lonergan B- courageous fight back to play in a flag, but bottom 6 in anyones estimation

Corey Enright A+ 4 time All Australian. star in anyones estimation

Harry Taylor B+ mature age debutant, hasn't put a put wrong. One of the best contested marks in the game

David Wojcinski B- Runs really fast, not much else to offer.

Joel Selwood A++ Outside of Chris Judd put together the finest first 100 games in memory. One of the 10 best footballers in the game.

Jimmy Bartel A+ Brownlow Medallist, Norm Smith Medallist, 2 x AA. thrives on the big stage. One word - champion

Andrew Mackie B decent footballer, not a star, not a hack.

Actually I've lost interest. I've only got to the centreline, but the points made. But just for clarity, theres another 13 players to go that I didn't get to. Of those 13 players theres 10 All Australian jumpers between.

Like DA, you're now my favourite poster too.

In fact, it would be fair to infer it's exactly the same, ergo, "Yes, that's what I said".

No, not exactly. It's open to interpretation, even if slightly, ergo, you misquoted said twitterer.

Are you all there? You know, up stairs?

Firstly you make the clearly wrong, and arguably idiotic statement that Geelong 2011 had no stars.

Then you argue amongst yourself to somehow try and deflect any real argument coming your way.

You then want everyone to forget you even said it, either because a: you realise how stupid it was, or b: you genuinely didn't want to derail the thread.

Finally you finish off with a smart arz comment asking H_T to provide an argument - after numerous times saying you didn't want to rehash that argument.

You sir, are my new favourite.

Iv actually lost track of whats going on here cause i dont care anymore except my damn hands keep clicking on the threads that keep getting bumped because im so bored at work.

But for the sake of it can you tell me what players were 'stars' for the 2011 season for the Cats. Has nothing to do with this thread of course but what the hell.

bugger it, I'm stupid enough to buy in. lets have a crack at this.

Josh Hunt B- grade player, lucky enough enough to play in 3 premierships.

Matthew Scarlett 6 time All Australian. One of the greatest full backs the game has seen.

Tom Lonergan B- courageous fight back to play in a flag, but bottom 6 in anyones estimation

Corey Enright A+ 4 time All Australian. star in anyones estimation

Harry Taylor B+ mature age debutant, hasn't put a put wrong. One of the best contested marks in the game

David Wojcinski B- Runs really fast, not much else to offer.

Joel Selwood A++ Outside of Chris Judd put together the finest first 100 games in memory. One of the 10 best footballers in the game.

Jimmy Bartel A+ Brownlow Medallist, Norm Smith Medallist, 2 x AA. thrives on the big stage. One word - champion

Andrew Mackie B decent footballer, not a star, not a hack.

Actually I've lost interest. I've only got to the centreline, but the points made. But just for clarity, theres another 13 players to go that I didn't get to. Of those 13 players theres 10 All Australian jumpers between.

Like DA, you're now my favourite poster too.

Nice, you listed there career achievements.

So how many of these were 'stars' for the 2011 season?

Back to the original point, I would prefer 2 A grade players like Watts and Trengove rather then a star like Cameron.

Your arguing in favor that you would prefer less stars to more A grade players I assume?

I am finding it funny how people are arguing that we need 'stars' and spruking players they think will be stars though none of these people have suggested any logical way to get any to the MFC. They just continue to try to de-rail this thread

Edited June 28, 201213 yr by olisik

Nice, you listed there career achievements.

So how many of these were 'stars' for the 2011 season?

Back to the original point, I would prefer 2 A grade players like Watts and Trengove rather then a star like Cameron.

Your arguing in favor that you would prefer less stars to more A grade players I assume?

I am finding it funny how people are arguing that we need 'stars' and spruking players they think will be stars though none of these people have suggested any logical way to get any to the MFC. They just continue to try to de-rail this thread

resistance is futile.

Over and out.

Had to bump this. Some of the comments are priceless. The kid is going to be a STAR! Hopefully Hollywood Hogan will be every bit as good for us

We should give the Scully

Unless we want to give up a viney, watts or a frawley then there is no point suggesting this.

Viney and Frawley? No. If they are silly enough to take Jack Watts? Hell yes!

Some of the comments are priceless.

Can't be bothered looking through - which comments?

Cameron will be a gun, but fix the bloody midfield. Dawes and Clark are enough company for Hogan to thrive under for the moment. I'd look at adding crumbers to that list before KPFs.