One relies on Mark Jamar too often and the other hurts teams in the midfield regardless of the rucks and can punish teams when he goes forward.

Cotchin is a mile in front of Moloney.

This argument is getting boring . Moloney is our best player .I say hes better .Most of you dont .

Swan gets tonnes of ball but doesn't hit targets .Judds skills aren't that silky either .Trengove is a better kick than all of the above .

Go buy yourselves a Tigers scarf and get a face tatt .

This argument is getting boring . Moloney is our best player .I say hes better .Most of you dont .

Swan gets tonnes of ball but doesn't hit targets .Judds skills aren't that silky either .Trengove is a better kick than all of the above .

Go buy yourselves a Tigers scarf and get a face tatt .

Terrible case of rose-coloured glasses when looking at our players.

Swan consistently hits targets, as does Judd, not taking into account the speed his usually traveling at and the defenses set up with the main aim of stopping him above anything else.

Wrong .Swan cannot kick a drop punt .Better by hand ,as with Judd .

Yeah right ,

Dont believe the hype on it .Wait till you see our bloke.

Still waiting for Moloney....

Haha, Biff. Still in love with Beamer?

13 disposals at 46% efficiency today. He's pissing all over his career in a different way if he keeps that up.

One warm day does not a summer make. Cotchin is not at Beamer's level yet. He may be on the way - but you are listening to too much KB on 1116.

Cotchin is and always has been miles ahead, only injuries held him up in his first couple of seasons he was a gem whenever he played and now everyone is seeing it. It's good to support your team and players but it doesn't make it right.

I was thinking about Moloney pre-match -- is he not suited to Neeld's gameplan?

Or is he just taking a while to adjust?

For a while now I've thought of Moloney as a one-trick pony, and it looks like even that trick isn't working for him at the moment.

I worry (for his sake) that under Neeld it won't work like it used to.