6 - Green

5 - Grimes

4 - Jamar

3 - McDonald

2 - Davey

1 - Jones

hard task today.

Disappointing game overall - very little run and not the pressure we have seen them apply over the last month. Nevertheless, here are my votes:

6: Bruce (He was one of the few who attacked the ball and attempted to run out of defence)

5: Bartram (would have been the best but I was annoyed by him letting Harvey run around him and kick a goal)

4: Dunn (just needs to be more consistent within a game)

3: Grimes (for his 2nd half)

2: Scully (great dash and commitment)

1: Green (was a target but needed to be moved on the ball)

Very disappointed in Joel MacDonald, Stefan Martin, Jared Rivers, Colin Sylvia

6. Bruce

5. Moloney

4. Grimes

3. Petterd

2. Sylvia

1. Tregove

6. Green

5. Grimes

4. Dunn

3. Bruce

2. Scully

1. Bartram

6. Grimes (only player to give them run out of an overly tall backline)

5. Green (presented well and helped get them back in the game up forward)

4. Jamar (battled well against one of the 3 best ruckmen in the comp and probably took the points, just!)

3. Scully (after the richmond game his best for the red and blue)

2. Davey (very good in patches, didn't do enough however)

1. Bennell (gave them a lot of run, impressive outing)

Edited May 1, 201015 yr by Tall Defence

6. Grimes

5. Bruce

4. Green

3. Jones

2. McDonald

1. Dunn

6. Green

5. McDonald

4. Davey

3. Jamar

2. Bruce

1. Scully

6 - Brad Green

5 - Clint Bartram

4 - James McDonald

3 - Mark Jamar

2 - Tom Scully

1 - Aaron Davey

6 - Bruce (can't believe there aren't more who gave him 6. I thought he was clearly our best 4 quarter player)

5 - Davey

4 - Green

3 - Grimes

2 - Bartram

1 - Scully

6. Bartram

5. Green

4. Davey

3. Scully

2. Jamar

1. Bennell

6. Bartram

5. Green

4. Davey

3. Scully

2. Jamar

1. Bennell

Please explain.

I thought he was just OK. Nothing very special, and needs to overcome his habit of doing nothing in the first half.

Please explain.

I thought he was just OK. Nothing very special, and needs to overcome his habit of doing nothing in the first half.

He was very good in the third quarter when Melbourne got a run on.

He was very good in the third quarter when Melbourne got a run on.

I didn't think he was that good. And playing one quarter out of four isn't good enough.

Needs to lift to keep his spot over Wonaeamirri, Jetta and Maric. As well as Cheney, Strauss, McNamara, Bail, McKenzie, and the upcoming return of Morton and Jurrah.

I didn't think he was that good. And playing one quarter out of four isn't good enough.

Needs to lift to keep his spot over Wonaeamirri, Jetta and Maric. As well as Cheney, Strauss, McNamara, Bail, McKenzie, and the upcoming return of Morton and Jurrah.

There's no reason to think Jetta is ahead of Bennell, Maric doesn't seem too likely to come in and Aussie will need to build a lot of fitness up before he'll be promoted.

Cheney, Strauss, Bail, Mckenzie and Jurrah all play different positions to Bennell.

Mark Jamar has polled votes every week and is our leader after Round 6:

57.042 Mark Jamar

51.255 James Frawley

48.898 Brent Moloney

48.713 James McDonald

35.228 Jack Grimes

28.994 Brad Green

26.292 Colin Sylvia

20.656 Ricky Petterd

20.034 Jack Trengove

17.419 Aaron Davey

16.100 Tom Scully

15.547 Matthew Bate

12.512 Jamie Bennell

12.491 Jordie McKenzie

11.660 Nathan Jones

9.717 Matthew Warnock

8.211 Rohan Bail

7.921 Lynden Dunn

5.250 Clint Bartram

4.160 Cameron Bruce

1.705 Joel Macdonald

There's no reason to think Jetta is ahead of Bennell, Maric doesn't seem too likely to come in and Aussie will need to build a lot of fitness up before he'll be promoted.

Cheney, Strauss, Bail, Mckenzie and Jurrah all play different positions to Bennell.

Jetta played better last year as a forward than Bennell has over the last few weeks (on average).

Aussie will take Bennell's spot in a canter if Bennell doesn't improve.

I think it will be hard to justify keeping Bennell in the side when those other players return from injury (the later ones, not McKenzie and Bail) or get in decent form. Unless Bennell improves. Which is the point of my first post I guess. He's not giving enough over 4 quarters atm.

5 Moloney

Please tell me you're joking

6 Grimes

5 Green

4 Scully

3 Jamar

2 Bartram

1 Davey