Now this is assuming we take (who i want obviously)

Scully

Trengove

Butcher

Black

#34 ? (Taylor if available)

PSD Ball

TEAM

BENNELL WARNOCK GARLAND

GRIMES FRAWLEY RIVERS

MORTON BRUCE DAVEY

BATE JURRAH SYLVIA

AUSSIE WATTS GREEN

JAMAR

SCULLY

BALL

I/C (Take your pic.... Love it)

BUTCHER

BLACK

BLEASE

STRAUSS

JONES

MARIC

PETTERD

MALONEY

TRENGOVE

MECKENZIE

MCDONALD

TAYLOR

Edited October 9, 200916 yr by Goose

It is Moloney FCS.

Maloney was in Police Academy.

It is Moloney FCS.

Maloney was in Police Academy.

sorry.... was excited when doing the team!!!

looks good doesnt it

I hate these threads.

sorry.... was excited when doing the team!!!

looks good doesnt it

Do you have any link on Taylor ?

It is Moloney FCS.

Maloney was in Police Academy.

Isnt it Mahoney in The movie

I'm sorry ...but i would prefer Moloney and Jones over Ball anyday...at least they can kick over 30 metres....l

Isnt it Mahoney in The movie

Oops. You're right. Apologies to the Goose.

I'm sorry ...but i would prefer Moloney and Jones over Ball anyday...at least they can kick over 30 metres....l

Ball was good enough to be included on GF day. Which means StKilda rate him In there best side. I find It hard to believe you would choose Jones and Moloney ANYDAY over Ball. Considering we took out the spoon I dont think our midfield Is looking that good. Scully and Trengove will take a couple of years at least to start hitting there straps and Ball will be a perfect fit to lead and teach the young kids.

Which means StKilda rate him In there best side. Scully and Trengove will take a couple of years at least to start hitting there straps and Ball will be a perfect fit to lead and teach the young kids.

Correct. Collingwood also rate him. All being well, he is a former Captain who would also fill a void for interim leadership at Melbourne. Jesse Smith is also interesting. I haven't seen alot of him to be honest but what i have is good.

Now this is assuming we take (who i want obviously)

Scully

Trengove

Butcher

Black

#34 ? (Taylor if available)

PSD Ball

TEAM

BENNELL WARNOCK GARLAND

GRIMES FRAWLEY RIVERS

MORTON BRUCE DAVEY

BATE JURRAH SYLVIA

AUSSIE WATTS GREEN

JAMAR

SCULLY

BALL

I/C (Take your pic.... Love it)

BUTCHER

BLACK

BLEASE

STRAUSS

JONES

MARIC

PETTERD

MALONEY

TRENGOVE

MECKENZIE

MCDONALD

TAYLOR

Whilst not wanting to tip a bucket on anyones enthusiasm for Jurrah & Watts is anyone else concerned about their physical size at the moment to play these key positions

Watts is still a few pre-seasons away from really asserting himself on any backline IMHO.... As one would expect....

But Jurrah is a bit different.... He has the ability to totally freak out any defender and pulls off the unthinkable.... His biggest asset is his X-Factor and his leap..... Body size is neither here nor there with Jurrah....

The team listed above looks great. The 'any of' IC list shows that we would be able to cover injured on-ballers pretty well. I agree with the size issue up forward and for this reason I hope we take a punt on Temel. Anyone have any idea if we would be safe (i.e. he won't already be taken) to pick him up with pick 18?

Also, does anyone know how Garland's foot is coming along? Wonna's hammy? I really hope those two are up and about for the preseason.

Now this is assuming we take (who i want obviously)

Scully

Trengove

Butcher

Black

#34 ? (Taylor if available)

PSD Ball

TEAM

BENNELL WARNOCK GARLAND

GRIMES FRAWLEY RIVERS

MORTON BRUCE DAVEY

BATE JURRAH SYLVIA

AUSSIE WATTS GREEN

JAMAR

SCULLY

BALL

I/C (Take your pic.... Love it)

BUTCHER

BLACK

BLEASE

STRAUSS

JONES

MARIC

PETTERD

MALONEY

TRENGOVE

MECKENZIE

MCDONALD

TAYLOR

How dare you not put Moloney in the 22! He had a great year will come 2nd in the B+F. I don't know why he is so underrated - he performs, provides some grunt and along with his presence on the field, his role offfield is important as a senior figure and big clubman. He will be one of the first picked every week in 2010 for sure.

You should also have

VALENTI

BARTRAM

DUNN

JETTA

CHENEY

MARTIN

MILLER

BUCKLEY

SPENCER

MEESEN

BELL

P.JOHNSON

There are some good ones in that group

Edited October 11, 200916 yr by Curry & Beer

How dare you not put Moloney in the 22! He had a great year will come 2nd in the B+F. I don't know why he is so underrated - he performs, provides some grunt and along with his presence on the field, his role offfield is important as a senior figure and big clubman. He will be one of the first picked every week in 2010 for sure.

You should also have

VALENTI

BARTRAM

DUNN

JETTA

CHENEY

MARTIN

MILLER

BUCKLEY

SPENCER

MEESEN

BELL

P.JOHNSON

There are some good ones in that group

Maybe Buckley,Jetta,Cheney....... the rest as far as i am concerned arent in the mix!!!!

Fair bit of wishful thinking there. The hardest part about these exercises is fitting everyone in. You've omitted several walk-up starts, including the captain, have no 2nd ruck and a third of the list on the I/C

Not sure if I like the idea of Jurrah played up the ground, he is so damaging near goal. And the opposite for Watts, in the future they'll be wanting to use his marking power & athleticism up the ground, I think you'll see him rotating through a forward flank or a wing, they certainly won't be playing him full forward without another mature body out there for support, Miller, possibly Martin with Jamar rotating through, Garland even... I like Green down there though.

Edited October 11, 200916 yr by torpedo