Which KPF should we draft?

[Guest Watts=Saviour]

1. Scully

2. Trengove

9? Talia

11. Panos

18. Griffiths

34. Daw

[leucopogon 1,519]

With Watts and Jurrah in the forwardline, I think we need a BIG body to take some attention off then.

Miller could fill this positionwhich would free up Watts who could play a roaming CHF with Jurrah being the 3rd tall, freeing him up aswell.

The big body doesn't need to be a star (as Mr. Morton alluded to Mooney), but I think it would be handy if they could kick a little better than Miller.

I think we draft one KPF with a big body and if a trade possibility arises in the next two years, we jump on it.

This sums up my thoughts almost to the letter. We just need a big body like Miller/PJ/Jamar up forward to take the oppositions best defender and allow Watts and Jurrah a little more freedom to develop their game. Will stand them in pretty good stead for the future.

I think only one of our high picks (probably 18) should be on a KPF and I'm leaning towards Black or Temel.

[Old Gregg 1]

1. Scully

2. Trengove

9? Talia

11. Panos

18. Griffiths

34. Daw

I highly doubt Daw will be taken in the national draft, let alone the third round.

[scarlett 247]

so who's happy with what we drafted now

[Felix 92]

so who's happy with what we drafted now

Sully & Trengove, without a doubt.

Gysberts, Tapscott, Fitzpatrick, Gawn have yet to see in action

Happy with 33% of our picks so far

And im sure Gysberts & Fitzpatrick will be a good player with the Demons, he will get a chance this season, I assume late into it, when the young kids start getting tired.

Do not know how Gawn is going with injury and Tapscott is out for the season... Although I am looking forward to Tapscott 180cm & 87kg, big boy and will only get bigger. picture that on the G.

[scarlett 247]

Sully & Trengove, without a doubt.

Gysberts, Tapscott, Fitzpatrick, Gawn have yet to see in action

Happy with 33% of our picks so far

And im sure Gysberts & Fitzpatrick will be a good player with the Demons, he will get a chance this season, I assume late into it, when the young kids start getting tired.

Do not know how Gawn is going with injury and Tapscott is out for the season... Although I am looking forward to Tapscott 180cm & 87kg, big boy and will only get bigger. picture that on the G.

from all things that i've heard, i cant wait to see max gawn get out and play a few games. a long time off just yet though

[Daz's Dee's 113]

I For one was/am a Majak Daw fan, Happy with Scully and Trengove (goes without saying), Don't know much about Gysberts but from all reports has the ability to make a good AFL player, I was wrapped to get Tapscott at 18 and can't wait too see him in action, Gawn again don't know much about but we need rucks lets hope, Fitzpatrick i watched during the under 18's carnival as he was rated as a potential top 30 pick IMO was average at best he is on our list so i will support him but i was hoping we called out Majak Daws name at pick 50 this kid will be a gem!

[Daz's Dee's 113]

1. Scully

2. Trengove

9? Talia

11. Panos

18. Griffiths

34. Daw

When did we ever have pick 9??

[e25 5]

When did we ever have pick 9??

Some people were convinced we'd trade Jamar or Rivers to Port.

You know, cos they're originally from SA.

[Daz's Dee's 113]

Some people were convinced we'd trade Jamar or Rivers to Port.

You know, cos they're originally from SA.

Ok cheers i remember now!

[4jacks 0]

Good bump.

Choosing 4 talls in one draft looks stupid from here... lol - Talia, Panos, Griffiths and Daw? Mad. Anyway, why have all them when you can have the man-mountain himself, Maxy GAAAAAAAAAAAAWWWWWWWWNNNNN

[e25 5]

Good bump.

Choosing 4 talls in one draft looks stupid from here... lol - Talia, Panos, Griffiths and Daw? Mad. Anyway, why have all them when you can have the man-mountain himself, Maxy GAAAAAAAAAAAAWWWWWWWWNNNNN

Or you could have taken Panos in the rookie draft?

Or Serhat Temel (snigger) with the last pick in that draft..?

You could even get him this year if you thought he was worth it.

The first line of the OP takes the cake - isn't that a contradiction in terms?!

[demonsflag555657 3]

I am very happy with what we have picked time will tell

[Demonland 71,582]

I know that everyone has to start somewhere but I can't help wondering about Panos who was an All Australian KPF at last year's under 18 carnival and even touted a top 10 pick at one stage. His name bobbed up this week as a goalkicker in the VFL reserves. Meantime, the likes of Butcher, Griffiths and Fitzpatrick aren't even playing ATM. It shows how risky it is to use early picks on prospective tall forwards and suggests that you have to be both fortunate and patient when selecting some of them.

[e25 5]

I know that everyone has to start somewhere but I can't help wondering about Panos who was an All Australian KPF at last year's under 18 carnival and even touted a top 10 pick at one stage. His name bobbed up this week as a goalkicker in the VFL reserves. Meantime, the likes of Butcher, Griffiths and Fitzpatrick aren't even playing ATM. It shows how risky it is to use early picks on prospective tall forwards and suggests that you have to be both fortunate and patient when selecting some of them.

I think it's fair to say that Panos bad more bulk at a younger age and he was good with his body work.

His skills, reading of he play, marking, engine, athleticism were all good, but not exceptional.

Recruiters expect draftees to fill out over time and learn the game from the coaches.

They draft based on things you can't teach, like exceptional athleticism, ferrari engine, freakish skills, strong pack marking in spite of slight frame, etc.

Things that will translate to AFL level and possibly allow the player to be elite.

Panos was/is a Jack of all trades.

Could still come out and prove a lot of people wrong.

[H_T 3,043]

I know that everyone has to start somewhere but I can't help wondering about Panos who was an All Australian KPF at last year's under 18 carnival and even touted a top 10 pick at one stage. His name bobbed up this week as a goalkicker in the VFL reserves. Meantime, the likes of Butcher, Griffiths and Fitzpatrick aren't even playing ATM. It shows how risky it is to use early picks on prospective tall forwards and suggests that you have to be both fortunate and patient when selecting some of them.

Good example of patience regarding early picks and how risky it can be : Scott Gumbleton ; Jack Watts.

And if it all works out - fortunate.

[scarlett 247]

whats Fitzpatrick look like as a footballer, im from a country town so do get to have a look at training or anything.

Edited April 15, 2010 by scarlett

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

whats Fitzpatrick look like as a footballer, im from a country town so do get to have a look at training or anything.

extremely ordinary the couple of times I have seen him. Have you ever had a kick with your mates and there is a bloke there who has pretty much never kicked a footy in his life? Yeah. OK that's over the top but at this stage he is 'tres ordinairre'

[e25 5]

extremely ordinary the couple of times I have seen him. Have you ever had a kick with your mates and there is a bloke there who has pretty much never kicked a footy in his life? Yeah. OK that's over the top but at this stage he is 'tres ordinairre'

That's a bit rough.

I'd rate him as a young Ben Holland but moe mobile and potential to be quite a bit better than dutchy was.