The match day report laid against Melbourne’s Colin Sylvia for striking Port Adelaide’s Josh Carr from Sunday’s match was assessed. It was the view of the panel that Sylvia’s action was a pushing motion and not a strike. The contact was also below that required to constitute a reportable offence and it was the view of the panel the Port Adelaide player accentuated the contact. No further action was taken.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tab...67/default.aspx

Now all he needs to do is play a bloody GOOD GAME! <_<

So he should get off..... The report was a disgrace!

Both Power boys got games though.... Which is nice!! Burgoyne the dirty [censored] got what he deserved for kneeing Davey when he was down.... Obviously Port realised that they were like fresh meat in Pentridge last year and have made a pact to get tougher this season.... But toughness is measured in different ways....

Try again Port!!

See ya in the showers

Carr probably instigated it as well.

As a mate said to me:

The match day report laid against Melbourne’s Colin Sylvia for striking Port Adelaide’s Josh Carr from Sunday’s match was assessed. The incident was assessed as intentional conduct (three points), high impact (three points), body contact (two points) and against Josh Carr (negative seven points). No further action was taken.

Carr probably instigated it as well.

As a mate said to me:

The match day report laid against Melbourne’s Colin Sylvia for striking Port Adelaide’s Josh Carr from Sunday’s match was assessed. The incident was assessed as intentional conduct (three points), high impact (three points), body contact (two points) and against Josh Carr (negative seven points). No further action was taken.

I said the exact same thing to the missus when we saw it on the news..... Any report against a player who is playing on JC.... NO ACTION!

Carr probably instigated it as well.

As a mate said to me:

The match day report laid against Melbourne’s Colin Sylvia for striking Port Adelaide’s Josh Carr from Sunday’s match was assessed. The incident was assessed as intentional conduct (three points), high impact (three points), body contact (two points) and against Josh Carr (negative seven points). No further action was taken.

I actually had a chuckle at that one.

Carr has made a career on baiting players and also how many times did he duck the head in that game? - pathetic.

I think he's lucky. It was quite a forceful blow to the throat, but I'm happy he got off. He shouldn't and probably won't be dropped so now he can help us beat Richmond next week.

Carr probably instigated it as well. As a mate said to me: The match day report laid against Melbourne?s Colin Sylvia for striking Port Adelaide?s Josh Carr from Sunday?s match was assessed. The incident was assessed as intentional conduct (three points), high impact (three points), body contact (two points) and against Josh Carr (negative seven points). No further action was taken.

Very good 45h should not have been reported

bringing up burgoynes report... the "brothers" dont usually do things like to each other, very suprised by the incident! i believe they are first cousins too?

I think he's lucky. It was quite a forceful blow to the throat, but I'm happy he got off. He shouldn't and probably won't be dropped so now he can help us beat Richmond next week.

I agree Rny. He needs to put the incident behind him (and the game) and concentrate on the task next week.

Lucky to get off???? Pfft!!!!!

It was a push that turned into one of the greatest dives of all time!

The only reason it went up was because of the dive which the umpire fell for............the camera angle made it look far worse than it was............and that's why it was thrown out!

So he should get off..... The report was a disgrace!

Both Power boys got games though.... Which is nice!! Burgoyne the dirty [censored] got what he deserved for kneeing Davey when he was down.... Obviously Port realised that they were like fresh meat in Pentridge last year and have made a pact to get tougher this season.... But toughness is measured in different ways....

Try again Port!!

See ya in the showers

Good onya Krazy, I thought the same thing as you when I finally saw it. Nothing in it. Gee the kid cops some negativity. But now he does need to try to work himself into the Dees gameplan.

I think he's lucky. It was quite a forceful blow to the throat, but I'm happy he got off. He shouldn't and probably won't be dropped so now he can help us beat Richmond next week.

Nahh I dont think there was much in it, It was sorta just a push in the throat but Carr made it look worse.