yussel_7

15 sunday games and only 1 night game, very little exposure on free to air tv. very happy to see that we don't have a home game at TD. overall i think the draw is ok but would've liked less sunday games

NO! I've seen a fair bit of him play. He has extremely poor decision making skills and hasn't been able to compete forward or back at AFL level, I think we should stay away from him

Mattner will fit in well at sydney, pretty quick and can give lots of run off half back and through the middle which is good for the SCG because its small. Kennelly has said that he wants to go back to Ireland at the end of this contract so they may be looking at a replacement

I agree with this and would like to see it happen, however Geelong may not want to give up that much for johnstone

I'd take Marc Murphy or Fev, fo everyone else at these two clubs pick 4 shouldn't be given up

While it's been reported that Alwyn Davey wants to play with Aaron, not sure he would go after the opportunity that Essendon gave him last yr. If it wasn't for his injury he probably would've played every game. As for Roughead i think it would be a good pick up, but how much would they want for him? if it was a straight swap for Trav that'd be nice but i think they'd want more

brett ratten, chris bond

i think wheatley makes our best 22, he uses the ball well and usually makes good decisions with his disposal, much more than i can say for daniel ward

I'd have to agree with u Benno. Signed

If we could pick up Judd that would be incredible, assuming he is unavailable for whatever reason we should be looking for a key position player like pavlich and riewoldt, two absolute guns. We need another big target forward who can kick goals and take pressure off other forwards, with either one of these two our forward line would increase in potency dramatically. In my opinion we lack some pace through the middle, with the exception of davey if he pushes up the ground. We have prolific ball winners and people who can put the ball in decent are for our forwards so i would rule out haselby, Dal Santo is very good but would we have to sacrifice too much for him?? Charman is a very good ruckman, also add some grunt to our side although can be undisiplined at times, for the right price would definetly take him Will be so disappointed if we got heath shaw, kicks like S***

So happy to see PJ developing well, he is still learning how to ruck at the highest level and is progressing well. Hopefully he can remain injury free and cement his place in the side. I think that he deserves more game time than he is currently getting, the coaching staff should throw him in the deep end and give him some game time against other no1 ruckmen. Hope he doesn't have any more rushes of blood and play on when in the goal square We've had two ruckmen move on (Simmonds and Jolly) after we had developed them. We need to show PJ that he is important and give him time so he doesn't leave as well.

I'm starting to get tired of seeing brad miller play. How can an AFL footballer be afraid to kick the ball? When he was forced to kick it was often not the right option or he'd just kick the ball as far as he could. Needs to prove his worth at Sandy, its time to give Newton a go or play lynden dunn there. Don't think it was Godfrey's best game, his disposal was woeful at times and Harvey was pretty influencial.

7 goals from 6 games is not exactly a great achievement, if the coaching staff didn't have enough faith to put him on the ground then how can they justify his selection this week. He was barely on the field in the 2nd half and when he was not effective at all. Ryan Hargraves will have no problem keeping up with Miller. His only advantage would be his strength and he will probably not be getting into too many one on one contests. Newton will get limited opportunities once Robbo is back so give him a go, maybe this could give Miller the same motivation it gave Yze knowing that he has to play for his spot. Who will take Daniel Cross, gets a lot of the ball and can do damage? assuming macca goes to west and godfrey on cooney

PJ should get given all the game time he can, he has good disposal of the ball and can kick a goal. He has shown that at Sandy, if he can get a string of games together i think he could develop into a solid player. Brad Miller was barely on the ground in the 2nd half of the game, unless he was injured which there has been no report of it was because he had been crap. The selection commitee has to take the next step and give him a few weeks down at sandy, he should have to earn his spot over the younger kids such as Bate and Newton. Can't have a CHF who is not kicking goals and not really contributing to any either, it equals a waste in my opinion. I know i am being harsh but i think it is time for brad miller to show that hecan hold down his position and perform every week rather than being hot one week and cold the next.

miller was terrible today, did nothing to justify why he should be in the team. Needs a go in the two's. Newton has performed well and should be rewarded for his good work.

I totally agree, Jamar has been given so many chances and hasn't been able to take advantage of them. He isn't going to get any better and hasn't been able to step up. Happy to see PJ get his shot, he is better around the ground than Jamar and is still developing as a ruckman. He has been a forward for most of his career before he came to us and is still developing, its time to give PJ his chance and I hope he takes the opportunity and can make the most of it All the best PJ

the way davey has played these past 2 games, needs a bit of the yze treatment if u ask me, really did very little.

Could Newton come in against the cats?

Jamar didn't exactly show anything special in any ruck contest today. I think PJ deserves a go in the side

PJ is a better option down forward than Jamar, more mobile and has played there most of his time as a junior and at West Coast. He can fill in the ruck role just as well as Jamar who only managed 9 hit outs today, against ruckmen who are average compared to the rest of the competition.

$40 is very reasonable, this is a good initiative taken by the club. As a 19 year old paying $150 on top of my MCC membership was a bit too much. I would happily pay $40 though and I think many other people would feel the same way.